PLANA与鼻撑在单侧唇裂术前正畸中的比较:三维人体测量研究
本研究比较了鼻撑(NE)与术前唇-牙槽-鼻接近(PLANA)两种简化婴儿术前正畸方案在单侧唇裂患儿中的效果。连续队列纳入26例NE(2023-2024)和23例PLANA(2024-2025)患儿,均由同一术者操作,采用基于鼻孔宽度比、鼻小柱角和鼻下点侧向位移的验证分级系统评估。PLANA在术后严重度分布(p=0.049)和优良率(χ²=7.48,p=0.024)上更优,鼻下点改善更显著(p=0.04)。
要点
- PLANA在单侧唇裂术前正畸中严重度分布和优良率优于鼻撑。
- PLANA对鼻下点侧向位移的改善显著大于鼻撑(p=0.04)。
- 两种方法在鼻孔宽度比和鼻小柱角改善上无显著差异。
核心结论
- 鼻撑和PLANA均能改善单侧唇裂患儿鼻唇形态,但PLANA术前正畸效果更优,尤其在鼻下点对线方面。
研究设计与样本
- 连续队列研究,纳入26例鼻撑(2023-2024)和23例PLANA(2024-2025)单侧唇裂患儿,均由同一术者完成术前正畸。
主要发现
- PLANA术后严重度分布更有利(p=0.049)。
- PLANA优良结局比例更高、差结局更少(χ²=7.48,p=0.024)。
- PLANA的鼻下点改善显著更大(p=0.04),鼻孔宽度比和鼻小柱角改善两组相当。
关键数值与推荐
- 采用基于鼻孔宽度比、鼻小柱角和鼻下点侧向位移的验证人体测量分级系统评估唇裂严重度(四级)和术前正畸结局(优/良/差)。
- 统计方法包括Fisher精确检验、卡方检验和Mann-Whitney U检验,p<0.05为显著。
临床怎么用
- PLANA可作为有效且可扩展的简化术前正畸策略,尤其关注鼻下点对线改善。
- 鼻撑仍是可选的简化方案,两种方法在鼻孔宽度和鼻小柱角改善上效果相当。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: As limitations of nasoalveolar molding (NAM), including labor intensity and reliance on specialized expertise and infrastructure, have become increasingly evident, interest has shifted toward simplified presurgical infant orthopedics (PSIO). Nasal Elevator (NE)-based protocols and the recently introduced Presurgical Lip-Alveolus-Nose Approximation (PLANA) represent such alternatives. However, these two simplified approaches have not been directly compared using objective three-dimensional analysis and a validated anthropometric grading system. This study compared NE-based PSIO and PLANA in infants with unilateral cleft lip. METHODS: Consecutive cohorts of 26 infants treated with NE (2023-2024) and 23 infants treated with PLANA (2024-2025) were analyzed; all PSIO was performed by the same surgeon. Cleft severity (four levels) and PSIO outcomes (Excellent/Good/Poor) were assessed using a validated anthropometric grading system based on nostril width ratio (NWR), columellar angle (CA), and subnasale lateral displacement (SN). Groups were compared using Fisher's exact test, chi-square testing, and Mann-Whitney U test (p < 0.05). RESULTS: Baseline characteristics were comparable between groups. PLANA achieved a more favorable post-PSIO severity distribution (p = 0.049) and a higher proportion of Excellent outcomes with fewer Poor outcomes (χ² = 7.48, p = 0.024). Improvement in SN was significantly greater with PLANA (p = 0.04), whereas improvements in NWR and CA were comparable between techniques. CONCLUSIONS: Both NE-based PSIO and PLANA improved nasolabial morphology in unilateral cleft lip. However, PLANA demonstrated superior presurgical orthopedic effectiveness, particularly in subnasale alignment, supporting its role as an effective and scalable PSIO strategy.
引用
- Tanikawa DYS, Figueroa ÁA. "Comparative Effectiveness of PLANA and Nasal Elevator in Presurgical Orthopedics: A 3D Anthropometric Study of Unilateral Cleft Lip.". Plast Reconstr Surg. 2026. PMID: 42160712. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000013220
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。