文献速递美容整形

美国区域性整形外科会议摘要转化为同行评议论文的转化率

Conversion Rate of Abstracts Presented at Regional Plastic Surgery Conferences in the United States.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Plast Surg · 2026-05-11

该研究评估了2022至2023年美国六个区域性整形外科会议的口头摘要转化为同行评议全文出版物的趋势,并与全国性会议比较。结果显示,部分区域性会议(CSPS、NESPS、SESPRS)的转化率(66.7%至68.4%)与全国性会议(65.7%至69.6%)相当,且更常在整形外科期刊发表。摘要年份、研究设计类型和会议地点显著影响转化odds和时间。

要点

  • CSPS、NESPS、SESPRS转化率66.7%至68.4%,与全国会议65.7%至69.6%相当。
  • 上述区域会议发表在整形外科期刊的比例87.3%至92.3%,高于全国会议的56.5%至80.0%。
  • 数据库、系统综述和回顾性临床研究提高2.5年转化odds(OR≥3.04,P≤0.036)。

核心结论

  • 区域性会议对研究指标贡献与全国会议相当,但实际影响和同行评议产出存在差异。
  • 这些趋势不一定劣于全国性会议。
  • 不同区域产生更多特定主题摘要,但这种专业化很少持续到发表的全文。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究使用2022和2023年区域性整形外科会议公开的口头摘要信息,通过关键词和作者姓名查找对应全文。
  • 评估了SESPRS、NESPS、NESPRS、CSPS、OVSPS和MWSPS六个区域会议,并与PSRC和AAPS全国会议比较。
  • 收集摘要主题、研究设计和作者机构/学位,评估其对2.5年内发表odds和滞后时间的影响。

主要发现

  • 2.5年发表时间(P=0.050)和odds(P<0.01)在各会议间差异显著。
  • 摘要主题构成和研究设计构成在各会议间差异显著(P<0.01)。
  • 发表摘要的期刊也因会议不同而差异显著(P<0.01)。
  • CSPS、NESPS、SESPRS转化率66.7%至68.4%,全国会议65.7%至69.6%,且区域会议更常在整形外科期刊发表(87.3%至92.3% vs. 56.5%至80.0%)。
  • 多因素分析中,摘要年份强烈影响2.5年内转化odds(OR=0.67,P<0.01);数据库、系统综述和回顾性临床研究提高转化odds(OR≥3.04,P≤0.036);MWSPS和OVSPS会议摘要odds较低(P≤0.012)。

临床怎么用

  • 区域性会议摘要可作为衡量学术生产力的有效指标,其转化率与全国会议相当。
  • 鼓励在区域性会议展示数据库、系统综述和回顾性临床研究,因其转化odds更高。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Conference presentations are a crucial instrument for disseminating research and measuring academic productivity in plastic surgery education. Much attention has been given to outcomes of abstracts presented at national conferences, but less so in regional settings. To better understand the validity and ultimate outcomes of abstracts presented at regional conferences, we evaluated their trends in abstract-to-peer-reviewed publication conversion. METHODS: Regional plastic surgery conferences' publicly available oral abstract information for 2022 and 2023 was used to find corresponding full-length publications using keywords and author names. Abstract topic, study design, and author institutions/degrees were collected and evaluated for their influence on publication odds and lag time within 2.5 years of presentation. RESULTS: Southeast (SESPRS), Northeast (NESPS), New England (NESPRS), California (CSPS), Ohio Valley (OVSPS), and Mountain West (MWSPS) conferences were evaluated and compared with national conferences [Plastic Surgery Research Council (PSRC) and American Association of Plastic Surgeons (AAPS) annual meetings]. 2.5-year publication time ( P =0.050) and odds ( P <0.01) differed significantly across conferences, as did the composition of abstract topics and study designs ( P <0.01). The journals that published abstracts also differed significantly by conference ( P <0.01). CSPS, NESPS, and SESPRS had comparable publication conversion rates (66.7% to 68.4%) as national conferences (65.7% to 69.6%) and published in plastic surgery journals more often (87.3% to 92.3% vs. 56.5% to 80.0%). Notably, NESPS and OVSPS abstracts presented on medical education and reconstruction/microsurgery more often, respectively, and also published these topics with greater frequency. On multivariate analysis, abstract year strongly influenced the odds of an abstract converting to a full-length, peer-reviewed, published manuscript within 2.5 years (OR=0.67, P <0.01). Database, systematic review, and retrospective clinical studies increased 2.5-year conversion odds (OR≥3.04, P ≤0.036), whereas MWSPS and OVSPS conference abstracts had lower odds ( P ≤0.012). The only significant predictor of the time from presentation to publication was presentation of an abstract at PSRC (β=-2.73, P =0.021). CONCLUSIONS: Regional conferences contribute equally to research metrics, but differences in real-world impact and peer-reviewed outputs exist. However, these trends are not necessarily inferior to those of national conferences. Different regions also generate more abstracts on specific plastic surgery topics, although such specializations rarely persist into published full-length manuscripts.

来源:Ann Plast Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Mordukhovich I, Park L, Patel M, et al. Conversion Rate of Abstracts Presented at Regional Plastic Surgery Conferences in the United States. Ann Plast Surg. 2026. PMID: 42130323. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000004773

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。