文献速递美容整形

面提升术研究严谨性评估:美国20年报告结局的范围综述

Assessing Rigor in Facelift Research: A Scoping Review of 20 Years of Reported Outcomes in the United States.
PubMed 文献 · Aesthet Surg J · 2026-01-01

结果显示结局定义与测量方法差异大,仅少数使用验证工具,多数研究MINORS评分低于推荐阈值,提示方法学质量中等至偏低。

要点

  • 面提升术研究结局定义与测量方法差异大,仅少数使用验证工具。
  • 多数研究MINORS评分低于推荐阈值,方法学质量中等至偏低。
  • 标准化结局报告与验证工具可提高技术间可比性与证据强度。

核心结论

  • 面提升术研究中结局定义和测量方法差异显著,验证工具使用有限,多数研究方法学质量中等至偏低。

主要发现

  • 回顾性设计占51.9%,前瞻性占25.9%,比较性研究占48.1%;混合技术占33.3%,技术未指明占25.9%。
  • 临床结局报告占70.4%,最常见为血肿(59.3%),仅25.0%定义测量标准且各不相同;患者满意度报告占22.2%,美学结局占18.5%,每种结局类型仅1项研究使用验证工具。
  • 63.0%的研究MINORS评分低于推荐阈值(比较性研究≥18,非比较性研究≥12)。

关键数值与推荐

  • MINORS推荐阈值:比较性研究≥18,非比较性研究≥12;63.0%的研究低于该阈值。

临床怎么用

  • 面提升术临床研究应优先采用验证工具和标准化结局定义,以提高技术间可比性和证据质量。

局限性

  • 仅纳入美国研究,排除同期其他手术,可能限制结果外推性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Emphasis on clinical and patient-reported outcomes has transformed research and quality-improvement efforts, with a growing push for standardized, validated outcome measures. This scoping review aimed to evaluate whether aesthetic surgery is meeting the current scientific standard by analyzing the scientific rigor and uniformity of outcomes reported in facelift research. PubMed/MEDLINE, Embase, and Scopus were searched for US studies reporting outcomes following surgical facelifts between July 2005 and July 2025. Studies involving concurrent procedures were excluded. Study design, senior author characteristics, interventions, outcomes, measurement methods, and quality (by Methodological Index for Non-Randomized Studies [MINORS] criteria) were evaluated. Twenty-seven out of 2101 studies met inclusion criteria. Most were conducted at an academic institution (66.7%) without funding (92.6%) by a male senior author (96.3%) with a median of 21 (interquartile range, 10-34) years in practice. Retrospective designs (51.9%) outnumbered prospective (25.9%), and 48.1% were comparative. Mixed facelift techniques were described in 33.3% and unspecified in 25.9%. Clinical outcomes were reported in 70.4%, most commonly hematoma (59.3%) with only 25.0% defining measurement criteria, which all differed. Patient satisfaction was reported in 22.2%, and aesthetic outcomes in 18.5%, with validated instruments used in only 1 study for each outcome type. Most studies (63.0%) scored below the recommended MINORS thresholds for comparative and noncomparative studies (≥18 and ≥12), indicating moderate to low methodological quality. Outcome definitions and measurement methods vary substantially in facelift research. Broader use of validated instruments and standardized reporting would improve comparability across techniques and strengthen evidence-based aesthetic facial surgical interventions. Level of Evidence: 3 (Therapeutic).

来源:Aesthet Surg J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hornick MM, Olsen TC, McCutchen AI, et al. Assessing Rigor in Facelift Research: A Scoping Review of 20 Years of Reported Outcomes in the United States. Aesthet Surg J. 2026. PMID: 41843484. doi:10.1093/asj/sjag005

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。