整形外科与泌尿外科性别肯定专科培训项目的比较分析
该横断面研究比较了美国88个整形外科和144个泌尿外科住院医师项目的生殖器手术培训、性别肯定专科培训机会及地理分布。结果显示整形外科仅9.1%设有性别肯定专科培训,而泌尿外科41%提供包含生殖器重建的专科培训,整形外科住院医师的生殖器重建暴露有限。
要点
- 整形外科住院医师对性别肯定生殖器重建的培训暴露有限。
- 泌尿外科提供更多包含生殖器重建的专科培训机会。
- 性别肯定专科培训自2017年以来在整形外科逐步扩展。
核心结论
- 尽管性别肯定医疗需求增加,整形外科住院医师的生殖器重建培训暴露有限,泌尿外科提供更多培训机会。
- 专业化的性别肯定外科教育仍然有限,不足以满足跨性别人群日益增长的需求。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,通过ACGME和AUA数据库识别美国认证的整合整形外科和泌尿外科住院医师项目。
- 共纳入232个项目,其中整形外科88个,泌尿外科144个;审查住院医师和机构网站获取轮转安排、性别肯定专科培训和性别肯定手术服务信息。
- 将未认证的生殖器重建专科培训纳入(若培训整形或泌尿外科医生),项目按美国地区分组,使用SPSS v28.0.1分析。
主要发现
- 8个整形外科机构(9.1%)和9个泌尿外科机构(6.3%)设有性别肯定专科培训(P = 0.42)。
- 59个泌尿外科项目(41%)提供包含生殖器重建的专科培训(P < 0.001)。
- 专科培训分布无显著地理差异。
- 41.2%设有性别肯定专科培训的项目未宣传性别肯定手术,而46.7%无专科培训的项目却宣传了性别肯定手术。
- 设有专科培训的项目更常提及「性别」门诊或轮转(P = 0.009);自2017年以来,整形外科性别肯定专科培训稳步扩展,多家主要机构至2026年启动项目。
临床怎么用
- 整形外科住院医师培训需加强性别肯定生殖器重建的暴露和训练。
- 关注泌尿外科在生殖器重建培训中的主导角色,促进多学科协作。
- 专科培训项目的扩展和宣传应匹配日益增长的性别肯定医疗需求。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Gender-affirming (GA) surgeries have increased over 400% in the past decade, yet plastic surgery (PRS) residents receive limited training in GA genital reconstruction. Although plastic and reconstructive surgery is central to GA care, urology also plays a key role. This cross-sectional study compares genital surgery training in urology and PRS residency programs, availability of GA fellowships, and geographic distribution, and outlines the history and growth of GA fellowships in PRS. METHODS: United States-based, accredited integrated PRS and urology residency programs were identified via the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) and American Urology Association (AUA) databases. Residency and institutional websites were then reviewed for rotation schedules, GA fellowships, and presence of GA surgical services. Unaccredited genital reconstruction fellowships were included if they trained plastic or urologic surgeons. Programs were grouped by US region. Analyses were performed using SPSS v28.0.1. RESULTS: Of 232 programs, 88 were PRS and 144 were urology. Gender-affirming fellowships existed at 8 PRS institutions (9.1%) and 9 urology institutions (6.3%) ( P = 0.42). However, 59 urology programs (41%) offered fellowships that included genital reconstruction ( P < 0.001). There was no significant geographic difference in fellowship distribution. Interestingly, 41.2% of programs with a GA fellowship did not advertise GA procedures, whereas 46.7% of those without fellowships did. Programs with fellowships more often referenced a "gender" clinic or rotation ( P = 0.009). Since 2017, PRS GA fellowships have steadily expanded, with several major institutions launching programs through 2026. CONCLUSION: Despite increasing demand for GA care, PRS residents have limited exposure to genital reconstruction, with urology offering more training opportunities. Specialized GA surgical education remains limited and insufficient given the growing needs of the transgender population.
引用
- Mamoun L, Miao X, Givant M, et al. Meeting the Demand: A Comparative Analysis of Plastic Surgery and Urology Gender-Affirming Fellowship Programs. Ann Plast Surg. 2026. PMID: 41616244. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000004666
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。