美国ACPA团队正畸照护模式:网站公示与培训现状
本研究通过ACPA目录获取204个团队和374名正畸医生,排除美国境外及重复后分析184个团队网站。仅46.7%团队公示正畸医生,25%为大学/医院模式,16.3%团队含颅面 fellowship 培训正畸医生,私立诊所团队含 fellowship 培训者的可能性更低(OR 0.086)。
要点
- 仅46.7%的ACPA团队网站公示正畸医生,与指南要求存在差距。
- 大学/医院模式占25%,私立诊所模式占18.5%,团队间差异显著(P<0.001)。
- 私立诊所团队含颅面 fellowship 培训正畸医生的可能性低于大学/医院团队(OR 0.086)。
核心结论
- ACPA团队正畸医生公示不一致且 fellowship 培训率低,照护模式与区域可及性存在结构差异。
研究设计与样本
- 从ACPA目录获取204个团队和374名正畸医生,排除美国境外及重复后分析184个团队网站。
- 按CDC四大 census 区域比较团队地理分布,并评估照护模式与 fellowship 培训状态。
主要发现
- 184个ACPA批准团队中仅46.7%在公开网站列出正畸医生。
- 最常见照护模式为大学/医院为主(25%),其次为私立诊所(18.5%),团队间差异显著(P<0.001)。
- 仅16.3%团队包含颅面 fellowship 培训正畸医生,超过半数未报告培训状态。
- 私立诊所团队含 fellowship 培训正畸医生的可能性低于大学/医院团队(OR 0.086;P<0.001)。
- 多数团队有1至2名正畸医生(均值1.84),区域或照护模式间无差异;南部团队和正畸医生占比最高(均33.2%),东北部最少。
临床怎么用
- 临床团队应确保正畸医生在公开渠道可识别,并明确照护模式与培训背景以促进跨学科协作。
- 私立诊所团队可考虑加强与 fellowship 培训正畸医生的合作以提升颅面照护一致性。
局限性
- 数据基于团队网站公示信息,可能低估实际参与的正畸医生及培训状态。
- 仅纳入美国ACPA团队,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: American Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Association (ACPA) teams consist of trained professionals collaborating in an interdisciplinary approach to optimize outcomes for patients with cleft palate. Orthodontic care is essential to correct dental malocclusion, guide maxillary growth, enhance surgical outcomes, and improve oral function and aesthetics. Although ACPA approval requires an orthodontist in the multidisciplinary team, the methods of delivering orthodontic care remain unclear. This project aims to elucidate how orthodontic care is integrated into ACPA teams. METHODS: A list of ACPA teams (n = 204) and reported orthodontists (n = 374) was obtained from the ACPA directory. Teams outside the US. and duplicate listings were excluded. Each team's website was reviewed to identify orthodontists, care delivery types (university/hospital, private practice, mixed, not listed), and orthodontic craniofacial fellowship status. Team geographic distribution was compared across the 4 US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Census regions: West, Midwest, South, and Northeast. RESULTS: Among 184 ACPA-approved teams, only 46.7% listed an orthodontist on their public websites, despite guidelines requiring orthodontic inclusion. The most common care model was university/hospital-based (25%), followed by private practice (18.5%), with variation across teams ( P < 0.001). Only 16.3% of teams included a craniofacial fellowship-trained orthodontist, whereas over half did not report training status. Private practice teams were less likely to include a fellowship-trained orthodontist compared to university/hospital-based teams (OR, 0.086; P < 0.001). Most teams had 1 to 2 orthodontists (mean, 1.84), with no difference by region or care model. Regionally, the South had the highest proportion of teams (33.2%) and orthodontists (33.2%), whereas the Northeast had the fewest. Fellowship-trained orthodontists were most common in the South but showed no regional difference ( P = 0.989). DISCUSSION: Orthodontists are inconsistently represented across ACPA teams with limited public reporting and low rates of fellowship training. Variation in care delivery models and regional access highlights structural gaps in interdisciplinary cleft care. Standardizing orthodontic integration and increasing fellowship training may improve the consistency and equity of craniofacial care nationwide.
引用
- Pitre KC, Hecox EE, McCall RR, et al. Orthodontic Care Delivery Across American Cleft Palate and Craniofacial Association (ACPA) Teams in the US. Ann Plast Surg. 2025. PMID: 41452828. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000004588
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。