从可读性到代表性:乳房缩小与增大手术在线患者教育材料的系统综述与荟萃分析
该系统综述与荟萃分析纳入23项评估乳房增大与缩小手术在线患者教育材料(OPEMs)的研究,涵盖传统、AI生成和社交媒体平台。3项研究的荟萃分析显示合并FKGL为12.28(95%CI: 11.16-13.41),二项检验证实100%的研究认为OPEMs超过六年级阅读水平(p=0.0005)。9项研究报告内容质量欠佳,3项研究发视视觉和语言代表性差异,AI生成材料有潜力但缺乏手术细节。
要点
- 乳房手术OPEMs的合并FKGL为12.28,远超推荐的六年级阅读水平
- 所有评估可读性的研究均报告OPEMs超过六年级水平(p=0.0005)
- 常见缺陷包括风险披露、来源标注和引用不足,且存在代表性差异
核心结论
- 乳房手术在线患者教育材料持续高于推荐可读性水平,常遗漏关键内容并存在代表性不平等。
- 需要标准化和改善数字患者教育内容以满足所有手术候选人的信息和文化需求。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与荟萃分析,纳入23项评估乳房增大与缩小手术在线患者教育材料的研究。
- 结局包括FKGL、SMOG评分、DISCERN和EQIP质量评估、视觉代表性多样性及AI性能。
- 对FKGL评分进行随机效应荟萃分析,并使用二项检验评估超过推荐可读性阈值的研究比例。
主要发现
- 3项研究的荟萃分析显示合并FKGL为12.28(95%CI: 11.16-13.41),异质性显著(I²=96.4%,p<0.0001)。
- 二项检验确认100%评估可读性的研究认为OPEMs超过六年级水平(p=0.0005)。
- 9项研究报告内容质量欠佳,常见缺陷包括风险披露、来源标注和引用不足。
- 3项研究发现教育视觉材料和内容可及性存在代表性和语言差异。
- AI生成材料显示潜力但常缺乏手术细微差别和细节。
关键数值与推荐
- 合并FKGL为12.28(95%CI: 11.16-13.41),基于3项研究的随机效应荟萃分析。
- 100%评估可读性的研究认为OPEMs超过六年级阅读水平(二项检验p=0.0005)。
- 9项研究报告内容质量欠佳,缺陷涉及风险披露、来源标注和引用。
临床怎么用
- 临床医生应意识到现有乳房手术在线患者教育材料可读性过高,可能影响患者理解。
- 使用或推荐患者教育材料时需评估其内容质量和代表性,必要时补充解释。
- AI生成材料可作为辅助但有局限,需人工审核以确保手术细节准确。
局限性
- 荟萃分析仅基于3项研究,异质性显著(I²=96.4%)。
- 原文未报告系统综述的检索范围和时间限制。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Online patient education materials (OPEMs) play a critical role in shaping patient decision-making for breast augmentation and reduction surgery. However, concerns persist regarding their readability, quality, and inclusivity. We present the first comprehensive systematic review and meta-analysis to evaluate OPEMs across traditional, artificial intelligence (AI)-generated, and social media platforms. METHODS: We systematically reviewed 23 studies evaluating OPEMs related to breast augmentation and reduction. Outcomes included the Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level (FKGL), Simple Measure of Gobbledygook (SMOG) scores, DISCERN and Ensuring quality information for patients quality assessments, diversity in visual representation, and AI performance. A random-effects meta-analysis was conducted on FKGL scores and binomial test was used to assess the proportion of studies exceeding the recommended readability thresholds. RESULTS: Meta-analysis of 3 studies revealed a pooled FKGL of 12.28 (95% CI: 11.16-13.41), with significant heterogeneity (I² = 96.4%, p < 0.0001). A binomial test confirmed that 100% of the studies evaluating readability concluded that OPEMs exceeded the sixth-grade level (p = 0.0005). Nine studies reported suboptimal content quality, with common deficiencies in risk disclosure, source attribution, and citation. Three studies found representation and linguistic disparities in educational visuals and content accessibility. AI-generated materials showed promise but often lacked surgical nuance and detail. CONCLUSION: Our findings suggest that OPEMs for breast surgery are consistently written above the recommended readability levels, frequently omit essential content, and exhibit inequities in representation. These findings demonstrate the need for standardizing and improving digital patient education content to meet the informational and cultural needs of all surgical candidates.
引用
- Nguyen AT, Bajaj K, Li RA, et al. From readability to representation: A systematic review and meta-analysis of online patient education in breast reduction and augmentation surgery. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2025. PMID: 41072175. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2025.09.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。