常用保湿产品对瘢痕模型经皮水分丢失与含水量的影响
结果显示产品间效果差异显著,Eucerin表现最佳,而液态硅酮(Strataderm)与BioOil效果甚微,提示基础保湿剂在瘢痕活跃期管理中的潜在价值。
要点
- Eucerin在提升含水量与正常化TEWL方面表现最佳,Sorbolene次之。
- 含保湿剂、润肤剂与封闭剂平衡配方的产品有客观证据支持其活跃期增生性瘢痕管理效果。
- 液态硅酮(Strataderm)与BioOil对含水量和TEWL影响甚微,硅酮凝胶贴片移除后因水分快速蒸发反而升高TEWL。
核心结论
- 常用瘢痕管理产品效果差异显著,液态硅酮相比基础保湿剂效用有限。
- 配方平衡的保湿产品在活跃期增生性瘢痕管理中有客观证据支持其有效性。
研究设计与样本
- 采用胶带剥离法在正常皮肤上模拟活跃瘢痕的高TEWL状态。
- 在基线与4小时内每小时记录TEWL和含水量测量值。
主要发现
- Eucerin效果最佳,显著提升含水量并正常化TEWL。
- Sorbolene排名第二,在含水量和TEWL调节方面均有明显改善。
- Alhydran结果不一,有效正常化TEWL但降低含水量。
- QV Lotion提升含水量但对TEWL影响极小;Aqueous Cream呈现非显著的TEWL正常化趋势。
- 硅酮凝胶贴片提供高含水量但移除后因保留水分快速蒸发导致TEWL升高;液态硅酮(Strataderm)与BioOil表现不佳。
临床怎么用
- 临床推荐瘢痕活跃期保湿产品时可优先考虑配方含保湿剂、润肤剂与封闭剂且平衡的产品。
- 对液态硅酮与BioOil在瘢痕管理中的效用应持谨慎态度,不宜作为首选推荐。
局限性
- 研究在正常皮肤的胶带剥离模型上进行,非真实瘢痕组织。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Moisturizing is a widely recommended and accessible approach to scar management, yet objective evidence supporting the efficacy of commonly used products remains limited. Research suggests that moisturizers may reduce hypertrophic scar activity by normalising transepidermal water loss (TEWL) and enhancing skin hydration. AIM: This study aimed to provide insights into the effect of generic moisturizers on TEWL and hydration in a scar model, helping clinicians make informed recommendations for scar treatment. METHODS: The performance of eight moisturizing products were evaluated using a tape-stripping method on normal skin to simulate the elevated TEWL conditions observed in active scars. Thirty participants were recruited based on power calculations, with TEWL and hydration measurements recorded at baseline and hourly for four hours. Untreated tape-stripped areas served as controls for each participant. RESULTS: Eucerin demonstrated the highest efficacy, significantly increasing hydration and normalising TEWL. Sorbolene ranked second, showing notable improvements in both hydration and TEWL regulation. Alhydran produced mixed results, effectively normalizing TEWL but reducing hydration. QV Lotion increased hydration but had minimal impact on TEWL. Aqueous Cream exhibited a non-significant trend toward TEWL normalisation. The silicone gel sheet provided high hydration levels but caused elevated TEWL after removal due to rapid evaporation of retained moisture. Liquid silicone (Strataderm) and BioOil performed poorly, with negligible effects on hydration and TEWL. CONCLUSION: These findings reveal significant variability in the effectiveness of common scar management products, emphasising the limited utility of liquid silicones compared to basic moisturizers. Products with balanced formulations of humectants, emollients, and occlusives showed objective evidence to indicate efficacy in managing hypertrophic scars during their active phase. This study offers evidence-based guidance for clinicians and highlights the need for further research to optimise formulations for scar management.
引用
- Klotz T, Moran H, Vu P, et al. Commonly recommended moisturising products: effect on transepidermal water loss and hydration in a scar model. Burns. 2025. PMID: 40865492. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2025.107629
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。