英国医学院课程中整形外科教学被侵蚀的横断面分析
本研究通过2023年4-6月开展的国家级整形外科教学项目,匿名收集了来自28所英国医学院109人的128份问卷,发现53.3%的英国医学院毕业生未接受过任何整形外科讲座或研讨会,97.6%的英国医学生认为课程中整形外科暴露不足,且网络研讨会后知识提升82.6%。
要点
- 53.3%的英国医学院毕业生未接受过任何整形外科讲座或研讨会,20.0%仅接受过一次。
- 97.6%的英国医学生认为课程中整形外科暴露不足,显著高于非英国同行(p=0.001)。
- 网络研讨会后知识提升82.6%(p<0.001),100%的参与者对整形外科作为职业的洞察有所改善。
核心结论
- 研究揭示并描述了英国医学院课程中整形外科教学不足的现状,及其对职业抱负、患者转诊模式、专业误解和竞争比等方面的负面影响。
- 网络研讨会教学项目被证明是增加整形外科知识和职业洞察的有效、可及且引人入胜的手段。
研究设计与样本
- 作者开发了一项国家级整形外科教学项目,于2023年4月至6月实施,通过随访问卷匿名收集参与者所在医学院课程中整形外科纳入情况以及教学项目效果的数据。
- 项目记录了228次出席,从109人中收集了128份独特问卷回复,代表28所不同的英国医学院。
主要发现
- 53.3%的英国医学院受访者在毕业时未接受过任何整形外科讲座或研讨会,另有20.0%报告仅接受过一次。
- 97.6%的英国医学生认为课程中整形外科暴露不足,显著多于非英国同行(p=0.001)。
- 网络研讨会前后主题知识增加了82.6%(p<0.001),100%的出席者报告对整形外科作为职业的洞察有所改善。
临床怎么用
- 网络研讨会教学项目可作为增加整形外科知识和职业洞察的有效、可及且引人入胜的手段。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Plastic surgery, as a specialty, faces a crisis of representation within UK medical school curricula. Several studies posit this, with some regarding it as one of the most poorly taught specialties within the curricula. Despite this, research examining medical students' curricular exposure to plastic surgery in the UK remains limited. METHOD: The authors developed a national plastic surgery teaching programme, delivered April-June 2023. Data regarding plastic surgery inclusion within the medical school curricula of participants, as well as teaching programme efficacy, was collected anonymously via follow-up questionnaires. RESULTS: The programme logged 228 attendances. Overall, 128 unique questionnaire responses were collected from 109 individuals, representing 28 different UK medical schools. The responses indicated that 53.3% of UK medical school attendees had not received any plastic surgery lectures or seminars by the time of graduation; a further 20.0% reported having received just one. Moreover, 97.6% of UK-based medical students perceived inadequate exposure to plastic surgery within their curriculum, which was significantly more than their non-UK counterparts (p=0.001). Pre- to post-webinar topic knowledge increased by 82.6% (p<0.001) and 100% of the attendees reported improvements in their insight into plastic surgery as a career. CONCLUSION: This study exposes and characterises the lack of plastic surgery teaching currently provided within UK medical school curricula. It highlights the negative repercussions of this on career aspirations, patient referral patterns, specialty misconceptions, competition ratios, and beyond. A webinar teaching programme was found to be an effective, accessible, and engaging means of increasing knowledge of plastic surgery and insight into the specialty as a career.
引用
- Wyatt F, Jordan C, Shah V, et al. The erosion of plastic surgery from UK medical school curricula: A cross-sectional current-state analysis. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2025. PMID: 40393085. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2025.04.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。