3D打印模型弥合鼻整形培训差距:手术教育中的有效性
本研究开发并验证了一种新型3D打印鼻整形训练模型,53名外科医生参与课程评估内容与表面效度,20名外科住院医师参与培训评估标准效度。所有外科医生(n=53,100%)认为模型有助于学习,91%(n=48)评价逼真度优秀或很好;住院医师OSAT评分从基线11.7/40(SD±1.80)提高至21.6/40(SD±1.79),P<.0001。结论认为3D鼻整形模型具有良好内容、表面和标准效度,可作为尸体解剖前训练辅助或主要训练方式。
要点
- 53名外科医生中100%认为3D鼻整形模型有助于学习与发展。
- 91%(n=48)的外科医生评价模型逼真度优秀或很好(对比尸体标本)。
- 住院医师OSAT评分从11.7/40(SD±1.80)升至21.6/40(SD±1.79),P<.0001。
核心结论
- 3D鼻整形模型具有良好内容效度、表面效度和标准效度,客观改善了住院医师的手术表现。
- 3D鼻整形模型可作为尸体解剖前训练辅助,为受训者在尸体解剖前配备基本技能,或在尸体获取有限的国家作为主要训练方式。
- 模型为培训下一代鼻整形外科医生提供了创新方法。
研究设计与样本
- 研究设计为模型开发与验证,使用专有3D打印技术设计并生产鼻整形模型。
- 在涉及53名外科医生的鼻整形课程中评估内容效度和表面效度。
- 在20名外科住院医师的培训课程中评估标准效度,使用客观技术技能结构化评估(OSAT)测量练习3D模型后的手术技能改善。
主要发现
- 所有外科医生(n=53,100%)表示鼻整形模型有助于其学习与发展。
- 91%(n=48)的外科医生将模型与尸体标本相比的逼真度评为优秀或很好。
- 标准效度评估显示外科住院医师OSAT评分从基线11.7/40(SD±1.80)提高至课程后21.6/40(SD±1.79),差异有统计学意义(P<.0001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 内容效度与表面效度:53名外科医生中100%(n=53)认为模型有助于学习与发展;91%(n=48)评价逼真度为优秀或很好。
- 标准效度:20名外科住院医师OSAT评分从基线11.7/40(SD±1.80)提高至21.6/40(SD±1.79),P<.0001。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为3D鼻整形模型可作为尸体解剖前训练辅助,让受训者在尸体解剖前掌握基本技能。
- 作者认为在尸体获取有限的国家,3D鼻整形模型可作为主要训练方式。
- 作者认为3D鼻整形模型为培训下一代鼻整形外科医生提供了创新方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Rhinoplasty is a common facial plastic surgery procedure for both functional and aesthetic indications. The use of 3-dimensional (3D) models has been reported as a potential method for providing hands-on training for learning rhinoplasty without jeopardizing patient care. OBJECTIVES: The objective of this study was to develop and validate a novel model for rhinoplasty training. METHODS: The rhinoplasty models were designed and produced with proprietary 3D printing technology. Face and content validity were assessed during a rhinoplasty course involving 53 surgeons. Criterion validity was evaluated in a training session with 20 surgical residents, measuring improvements in surgical skills after practice with the 3D models, with an objective structured assessment of technical skills (OSAT). RESULTS: All surgeons (n = 53, 100%) stated that the rhinoplasty model aided in their learning and development. In all, 91% (n = 48) of surgeons rated the realism of the model as excellent or very good in comparison to cadaveric specimens. Assessment of criterion validity showed a statistically significant improvement in OSAT scores among surgical residents, increasing from a baseline of 11.7/40 (SD ± 1.80) to 21.6/40 (SD ± 1.79) post session (P < .0001). CONCLUSIONS: The 3D rhinoplasty models showed good content, face, and criterion validity, objectively improving residents' surgical performance. Rhinoplasty 3D models may serve as a precadaveric training adjunct, equipping trainees with fundamental skills before cadaveric dissection, or as a primary training modality in countries with limited cadaver access. Therefore the models offer an innovative approach to training the next generation of rhinoplasty surgeons.
引用
- Rehman U, Polglase N, Kahn D, et al. Bridging the Gap in Rhinoplasty Training: The Effectiveness of 3D Printed Models in Surgical Education. Aesthet Surg J. 2025. PMID: 40129179. doi:10.1093/asj/sjaf045
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。