新型显微外科教学模拟器Microsurgery Arena的面部效度与结构效度
本研究评估新型低保真显微外科模拟器Microsurgery Arena的结构效度与面部效度。21名外科受训者参加为期3天的显微外科入门技能课程,在课程前后完成「slalom」和「tie-the-knot」两项协调练习并由3名独立评估者使用Stanford显微外科住院医师培训量表评分。课程前后评分定量分析显示所有考察技能均有统计学显著改善,面部效度评估获得参与者高度正面反馈,模型能区分训练前后的技能水平,支持其结构效度。
要点
- 21名外科受训者参加3天显微外科入门技能课程,课程前后完成两项协调练习。
- 课程前后评分比较显示所有考察技能均有统计学显著改善。
- 面部效度评估显示绝大多数参与者认为该设备作为显微外科初始训练模型极其或非常有用。
核心结论
- 课程前后评分定量分析显示所有考察技能均有统计学显著改善,面部效度评估获得参与者高度正面反馈,模型能区分训练前后技能水平,支持其结构效度。
- 作为低成本、易获取的模型,该模拟器为培养基本显微外科技能提供了标准化方法,有潜力作为学生、住院医师和显微外科新手的有效评估与培训工具。
研究设计与样本
- 21名外科受训者参加为期3天的显微外科入门技能课程,在课程前后完成「slalom」和「tie-the-knot」两项预定义协调练习并记录完成时间。
- 练习视频经匿名化、随机化后由3名独立评估者(一名资深实验显微外科医师、一名资深临床显微外科医师和一名初级住院医师)使用Stanford显微外科住院医师培训量表评估。
- 参与者在课程结束时完成人口学问卷和面部效度问卷。
主要发现
- 课程前后评分的定量分析显示所有考察技能均有统计学显著改善。
- 面部效度评估显示参与者反馈高度正面,绝大多数候选人认为该设备作为显微外科初始训练模型极其或非常有用。
- 该模型能区分训练前后的技能水平,支持其结构效度。
关键数值与推荐
- 使用Stanford显微外科住院医师培训量表由3名独立评估者评分。
- 评估两项预定义协调练习:「slalom」和「tie-the-knot」。
临床怎么用
- 作为低成本、易获取的模型,该模拟器为培养基本显微外科技能提供了标准化方法。
- 该模拟器有潜力作为学生、住院医师和显微外科新手的有效评估与培训工具,有助于改善显微外科培训项目中的技能获取。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Simulation in microsurgery is essential for skill acquisition and maintenance. This study evaluated the construct and face validity of the Microsurgery Arena, a low-fidelity simulator designed to improve hand and wrist movements under the microscope, enhance instrument handling and knot-tying skills, and consistently assess user performance. Twenty-one surgical trainees participated in 3-day introductory microsurgical skills courses. Participants performed 2 predefined coordination exercises, "slalom" and "tie-the-knot," before and after the course. The time required to complete the exercises was recorded. The videos of the exercises were anonymized, randomized, and evaluated by 3 independent raters-a senior experimental microsurgeon, a senior clinical microsurgeon, and a junior resident-using the Stanford Microsurgery Residents Training Scale. Participants also completed demographic and face validity questionnaires at the end of the course. Quantitative analysis of pre-course scores vs post-course scores showed a statistically significant improvement in all examined skills. Moreover, the face validity assessment revealed highly positive feedback from the participants. The vast majority of candidates found the device extremely or very useful as an initial training model in microsurgery. Moreover, the model demonstrated its ability to discriminate between skill levels before and after training, supporting its construct validity. As a low-cost and accessible model, it provides a standardized approach for developing essential microsurgical skills. This simulator has the potential to serve as an effective assessment and training tool for students, residents, and microsurgical novices, contributing to improved skill acquisition in microsurgical training programs.
引用
- Costa F, Ballestín A, Srinivasan J, et al. Face and construct validity of a novel simulator for microsurgical education: Microsurgery Arena. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2025. PMID: 40138754. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2025.02.051
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。