文献速递显微修复重建

人类与机器:整形与重建外科决策的未来

Human vs Machine: The Future of Decision-making in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery.
PubMed 文献 · Aesthet Surg J · 2025-01-01

本研究比较ChatGPT-4o(omni)与Gemini Advanced在阅读继续医学教育文章前后回答22道选择题的表现,并与住院医师对比。结果显示住院医师读文章后平均分显著提高;ChatGPT-4o读文章前后无显著差异,Gemini Advanced显著提高;两个大语言模型在阅读文章前后准确率均值均高于住院医师组。作者认为大语言模型有潜力作为传统学习环境的补充工具。

要点

  • 住院医师阅读文章后平均分显著提高。
  • ChatGPT-4o阅读文章前后得分无显著差异,Gemini Advanced显著提高。
  • ChatGPT-4o与Gemini Advanced在阅读文章前后准确率均值均高于住院医师组。

核心结论

  • 作者认为大语言模型在医学教育中的应用前景良好,随着模型日益精细,有潜力作为传统学习环境的补充工具,帮助弥合理论知识与实践之间的差距。

研究设计与样本

  • 参与者和大语言模型完成22道选择题以评估对继续医学教育主题的基线知识,初始时两者均未阅读文章;大语言模型在无痕模式下重复测试6天;阅读文章后提取并分析两者回答。

主要发现

  • 住院医师组阅读文章后平均分显著提高。
  • ChatGPT-4o(omni)组阅读文章前后得分无显著差异。
  • Gemini Advanced组阅读文章后得分显著提高。
  • ChatGPT-4o和Gemini Advanced组在阅读文章前后准确率均值均高于住院医师组。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为大语言模型有潜力作为传统学习环境的补充工具,帮助弥合理论知识与实践之间的差距。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Artificial intelligence-driven technologies offer transformative potential in plastic surgery, spanning preoperative planning, surgical procedures, and postoperative care, with the promise of improved patient outcomes. OBJECTIVES: To compare the web-based ChatGPT-4o (omni; OpenAI, San Francisco, CA) and Gemini Advanced (Alphabet Inc., Mountain View, CA), focusing on their data upload feature and examining outcomes before and after exposure to continuing medical education (CME) articles, particularly regarding their efficacy relative to human participants. METHODS: Participants and large language models (LLMs) completed 22 multiple-choice questions to assess baseline knowledge of CME topics. Initially, both LLMs and participants answered without article access. In incognito mode, the LLMs repeated the tests over 6 days. After accessing the articles, responses from both LLMs and participants were extracted and analyzed. RESULTS: There was a significant increase in mean scores after the article was read in the resident group, indicating a significant rise. In the LLM groups, the ChatGPT-4o (omni) group showed no significant difference between pre- and postarticle scores, but the Gemini Advanced group demonstrated a significant increase. It can be stated that the ChatGPT-4o and Gemini Advanced groups have higher accuracy means compared with the resident group in both pre- and postarticle periods. CONCLUSIONS: The analysis between human participants and LLMs indicates promising implications for the incorporation of LLMs in medical education. Because these models increase in sophistication, they offer the potential to serve as supplementary tools within traditional learning environments. This could aid in bridging the gap between theoretical knowledge and practical implementation.

来源:Aesthet Surg J,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Duran A, Demiröz A, Çörtük O, et al. Human vs Machine: The Future of Decision-making in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery. Aesthet Surg J. 2025. PMID: 39862057. doi:10.1093/asj/sjaf015

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。