文献速递瘢痕与激光烧伤创面修复

随机对照患者内单盲预试验:评估12周真空按摩疗法对成年烧伤幸存者的疗效

Randomized, controlled, within-patient, single-blinded pilot study to evaluate the efficacy of 12-weeks of endermotherapy with adult burn survivors.
PubMed 文献 · Burns · 2024-09-22

前瞻性随机对照患者内单盲预试验,16例烧伤幸存者完成,每例两个匹配瘢痕随机分为常规护理对照组或真空按摩加常规护理组,每周3次共12周。线性混合模型分析显示各皮肤特征均无显著即时或长期治疗效应,但两组随时间弹性与红斑增加、经皮水分丢失减少;受试者满意度均值为4/5(SD=1.5),感知有效性均值为8/10(SD=1.9)。

要点

  • 真空按摩组与对照组在弹性、红斑、黑色素、厚度或经皮水分丢失上均无显著时间×治疗交互作用。
  • 两组随时间均出现弹性与红斑显著增加、经皮水分丢失显著减少,与持续常规护理相关。
  • 受试者满意度均值4/5(SD=1.5),感知有效性均值8/10(SD=1.9),尽管客观指标无改善。

核心结论

  • 本预试验未发现真空按摩疗法对弹性、红斑、黑色素、厚度或经皮水分丢失有治疗获益,但发现弹性、红斑和经皮水分丢失随时间改善。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性、随机、对照、患者内、单盲临床试验,最初设计为全效能研究,因COVID-19限制而限于预试验。
  • 19例烧伤幸存者同意参与,16例完成研究;每例两个同质患者内瘢痕随机分为常规护理对照组或真空按摩加常规护理组。
  • 真空按摩由认证按摩治疗师提供,每周3次共12周;每4周在机械按摩治疗前后即刻评估瘢痕特征。
  • 评估包括弹性(Cutometer)、红斑和黑色素(Mexameter)、经皮水分丢失(Tewameter)和厚度(高频超声)。
  • 采用线性混合模型分析检验即时和长期治疗效应。

主要发现

  • ANOVA分析显示弹性、红斑、黑色素、厚度或经皮水分丢失的时间×治疗交互作用均不显著。
  • 对照组和治疗组随时间均出现弹性与红斑显著增加、经皮水分丢失显著减少,与持续常规护理一致。
  • 任何皮肤特征均无统计学显著的即时或长期治疗效应。
  • 受试者满意度均值4/5(SD=1.5),感知有效性均值8/10(SD=1.9)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者结论指出,尽管治疗瘢痕部位缺乏客观改善,受试者对结果满意并认为真空按摩非常有效。
  • 作者认为需要进一步高质量研究以更好地为临床医生提供患者教育和治疗决策依据,针对这一昂贵、负担重但受试者满意度高的治疗方法。

局限性

  • 最初设计为全效能研究,因COVID-19限制而限于预试验。
  • 19例烧伤幸存者同意参与,16例完成研究。
  • 作者结论指出需要进一步高质量研究。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Vacuum massage, or endermotherapy, is applied to scar tissue with the primary therapeutic goal of promoting structural or physiological changes. These changes are intended to enhance pliability, enabling the skin to possess the strength and elasticity required for normal mobility. The advantage of vacuum massage compared to therapist-generated manual massage is that it provides a standardized dosage using rollers and suction valves to mobilize the tissue. However, research documenting and supporting its impact on post-burn hypertrophic scar is lacking. Thus, this study was designed to objectively characterize the changes in scar elasticity, erythema, melanin, thickness, and transepidermal water loss immediately after a vacuum massage session and after a 12-week course of treatment compared to intra-individual matched control scars. METHODS: We conducted a prospective, randomized, controlled, within-patient, single-blinded clinical trial, initially designed as a fully-powered study but limited to a pilot study due to COVID-19 restrictions. Nineteen burn survivors consented to participate and 16 completed the study. Two homogeneous, intra-individual scars were randomized to usual care control or vacuum massage therapy plus usual care. Vacuum massage interventions were provided by a certified massage therapist three times per week for 12 weeks. Scar characteristics were evaluated every four weeks immediately before and after mechanical massage treatment. The evaluations included measurements of elasticity (Cutometer), erythema and melanin (Mexameter), transepidermal water loss (TEWL) (Tewameter), and thickness (high-frequency ultrasound). Linear mixed-model analyses were performed to test for immediate and long-term treatment effects. RESULTS: The ANOVA analyses revealed a non-significant time:treatment interaction for elasticity, erythema, melanin, thickness, or TEWL. There was a significant increase in elasticity and erythema and a decrease in TEWL in both the control and treatment sites over time with consistent standard care. However, there was no statistically significant immediate or long-term treatment effect for any of the skin characteristics. Nonetheless, the mean participant satisfaction was 4/5 (SD = 1.5) and the mean participant perception of effectiveness was 8/10 (SD = 1.9). CONCLUSIONS: This pilot study did not find a treatment benefit of vacuum massage therapy for elasticity, erythema, melanin, thickness or TEWL, but it did find an improvement with time in elasticity, erythema and TEWL. Despite the lack of objective improvement of the treated scar site, participants were satisfied with the results and believed vacuum massage was very effective. Further high-quality research is required to better inform clinicians patient education and treatment decisions for this costly, burdensome treatment approach that has high participant satisfaction.

来源:Burns,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nedelec B, Edger-Lacoursière Z, Gauthier N, et al. Randomized, controlled, within-patient, single-blinded pilot study to evaluate the efficacy of 12-weeks of endermotherapy with adult burn survivors. Burns. 2024. PMID: 39343632. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2024.09.008

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。