成人烧伤护理价值医疗核心指标集的开发
本研究通过三轮改良全国Delphi研究,在27名患者、63名烧伤护理专业人员和23名研究人员中达成共识,选出10项结局和4项质量指标。经临床实践评估后,除共享决策外均保留,形成由9种患者报告结局工具或临床测量评估的VBHC烧伤核心集,评估时间点为出院时、出院后2周、3个月、12个月及此后每年。
要点
- 核心集含疼痛、伤口愈合、身体活动、自我照护、独立性、重返工作、抑郁、瘙痒、瘢痕柔韧性和重返学校10项结局。
- 质量指标包括共享决策、接受后照护的患者数、烧伤深度确定和主动关节活动度评估。
- 核心集在荷兰烧伤护理中系统监测和分析,以改善护理和患者相关结局。
核心结论
- 开发了对烧伤患者和烧伤护理专业人员重要的结局与质量指标组成的VBHC烧伤核心集。
- 该核心集现已在荷兰烧伤护理中系统监测和分析,以改善护理和患者相关结局。
- 作者认为该核心集可为其他国家提供启发。
研究设计与样本
- 三轮改良全国Delphi研究,包括44项结局和24项质量指标,在荷兰患者、烧伤护理专业人员和研究人员中达成共识。
- 条目采用九点Likert量表评分,各组中≥70%认为重要的条目被选中。
- 随后基于文献综述识别量化所选结局的工具,并在共识会议上根据荷兰共识标准集和荷兰健康差异专家中心的建议选择工具。
- 时间评估点选择反映烧伤护理和患者康复过程。
- 最后在临床实践中评估初始核心集,形成调整后的VBHC烧伤核心集。
主要发现
- 27名患者、63名烧伤护理专业人员和23名研究人员参与。
- Delphi研究选出10项结局和4项质量指标。
- 结局包括疼痛、伤口愈合、身体活动、自我照护、独立性、重返工作、抑郁、瘙痒、瘢痕柔韧性和重返学校。
- 质量指标包括共享决策、接受后照护的患者数、烧伤深度确定和主动关节活动度评估。
- 临床实践评估后,核心集包括除共享决策外的所有条目,由9种患者报告结局工具评估或在临床护理中测量,评估时间点为出院时、出院后2周、3个月、12个月及此后每年。
关键数值与推荐
- 条目选择标准为各组中≥70%认为重要。
- 核心集包括10项结局和4项质量指标,临床实践评估后保留除共享决策外的所有条目。
- 评估时间点为出院时、出院后2周、3个月、12个月及此后每年。
临床怎么用
- VBHC烧伤核心集已在荷兰烧伤护理中系统监测和分析,以改善护理和患者相关结局。
- 作者认为该核心集可为其他国家提供启发。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Value-based healthcare (VBHC) is increasingly implemented in healthcare worldwide. Transparent measurement of the outcomes most important and relevant to patients is essential in VBHC, which is supported by a core set of most important quality indicators and outcomes. Therefore, the aim of this study was to develop a VBHC-burns core set for adult burn patients. METHODS: A three-round modified national Delphi study, including 44 outcomes and 24 quality indicators, was conducted to reach consensus among Dutch patients, burn care professionals and researchers. Items were rated on a nine-point Likert scale and selected if ≥ 70% in each group considered an item 'important'. Subsequently, instruments quantifying selected outcomes were identified based on a literature review and were chosen in a consensus meeting using recommendations from the Dutch consensus-based standard set and the Dutch Centre of Expertise on Health Disparities. Time assessment points were chosen to reflect the burn care and patient recovery process. Finally, the initial core set was evaluated in practice, leading to the adapted VBHC-burns core set. RESULTS: Twenty-seven patients, 63 burn care professionals and 23 researchers participated. Ten outcomes and four quality indicators were selected in the Delphi study, including the outcomes pain, wound healing, physical activity, self-care, independence, return to work, depression, itching, scar flexibility and return to school. Quality indicators included shared decision-making (SDM), the number of patients receiving aftercare, determination of burn depth, and assessment of active range of motion. After evaluation of its use in clinical practice, the core set included all items except SDM, which are assessed by 9 patient-reported outcome instruments or measured in clinical care. Assessment time points included are at discharge, 2 weeks, 3 months, 12 months after discharge and annually afterwards. CONCLUSION: A VBHC-burns core set was developed, consisting of outcomes and quality indicators that are important to burn patients and burn care professionals. The VBHC-burns core set is now systemically monitored and analysed in Dutch burn care to improve care and patient relevant outcomes. As improving burn care and patient relevant outcomes is important worldwide, the developed VBHC-burns core set could be inspiring for other countries.
引用
- Spronk I, van Uden D, Lansdorp CA, et al. Development of a value-based healthcare burns core set for adult burn care. Burns. 2024. PMID: 38902131. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2024.03.038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。