探究损伤意图的错误分类:一项烧伤登记研究
该研究分析了印度南部一家新数字化单中心烧伤登记处2016年2月1日至2022年2月28日的数据,纳入全部1930例患者,描述不同损伤意图分类的人口学和临床特征,发现损伤意图数据缺失率为12.6%,意图被覆盖的病例占1.5%,女性高TBSA烧伤可能更易被错误分类。
要点
- 损伤意图数据缺失率为12.6%,是该数据集中最常见的缺失变量。
- 意图被覆盖的病例占1.5%,该组女性比例更高(62.1% vs 48.5%),中位TBSA更高(77.5% vs 27.5%)。
- 女性高TBSA烧伤可能更易被错误分类,应成为未来研究重点。
核心结论
- 部分亚组如女性高TBSA烧伤似乎更可能被错误分类,应成为未来研究的重点。
- 通过记录临床印象、患者报告意图的变化以及使用统一的意图数据元素来标准化数据收集,可提高监测数据质量。
- 作者建议将损伤意图记录为独立变量,不应与损伤原因的其他要素(如机制)混合。
研究设计与样本
- 描述性、假设生成研究,使用印度南部一家新数字化单中心烧伤登记处的数据,分析2016年2月1日至2022年2月28日的数据,纳入数据集中全部患者(n=1930)。
主要发现
- 损伤意图数据缺失率为12.6%,是该数据集中最常见的缺失变量。
- “意外”损伤在男性与女性之间的时间、年龄和总烧伤面积(TBSA)分布相似。
- “他杀”损伤在女性中更常见;“自杀”损伤对男性和女性的影响相同。
- 女性“自杀”损伤报告减少,与此同时被归类为“其他”或数据缺失的高TBSA损伤增加。
- 意图被覆盖的病例占1.5%,该组女性比例更高(62.1% vs 48.5%),中位TBSA更高(77.5% vs 27.5%)。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议记录临床印象、患者报告意图的变化,并使用统一的意图数据元素来标准化数据收集。
- 作者建议将损伤意图记录为独立变量,不应与损伤原因的其他要素(如机制)混合。
局限性
- 这是一项单中心研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Burn registers are an important source of surveillance data on injury intent. These data are considered essential to inform prevention activities. In South Asia, intentional burn injuries are thought to disproportionately affect women. Assessment of injury intent is difficult because it is influenced by personal, family, social, and legal sensitivities. This can introduce misclassification into data, and bias analyses. We conducted a descriptive, hypothesis generating study to explore misclassification of injury intent using data from a newly digitised single centre burn register in south India. METHODS: Data from 1st February 2016 to 28th February 2022 were analysed. All patients in the data set were included in the study (n = 1930). Demographic and clinical characteristics for patients are described for each classification of injury intent. All data cleaning and analyses were completed using RStudio. RESULTS: Injury intent data were missing for 12.6% of cases. It was the most commonly missing variable in the data set. "Accidental" injuries had a similar distribution over time, age, and total body surface area (TBSA) for males and females. "Homicidal" injuries were more common in females. Injuries reported as "Suicidal" affected men and women equally. A decrease in reporting of "Suicidal" injuries in females corresponded to an increase in high TBSA injuries classified as 'Other' or with missing data. Overwriting of injury intent was present in 1.5% of cases. The overwritten group had a greater proportion of females (62.1% vs. 48.5%) and higher median TBSA (77.5% vs. 27.5%) compared to the group where intent was not overwritten. CONCLUSION: Our findings indicate that some subgroups, such as females with high TBSA burns, appear to be more likely to be misclassified and should be the focus of future research. They also highlight that quality of surveillance data could be improved by recording of clinical impression, change in patient reported intent, and use of a common data element for intent to standardise data collection. We also recommend that injury intent is recorded as a unique variable and should not be mixed with other elements of injury causation (e.g. mechanism). Although this is a single centre study, the methods will be of interest to those who utilise routinely collected data and wish to reduce misclassification of this important variable.
引用
- Bebbington E, Kakola M, Majgi SM, et al. Exploring misclassification of injury intent: A burn register study. Burns. 2024. PMID: 38862344. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2024.05.010
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。