自体脂肪注射治疗腭咽闭合不全的评价:综述与整合数据分析
该系统综述检索2013至2023年五个数据库,纳入20项研究,评估自体脂肪移植治疗腭咽闭合不全。多数患者有腭裂病史(78.2%),脂肪多取自腹部(64.3%),平均注射量6.3 mL。七项研究的感知言语评估评分术后持续改善,17项研究报告并发症汇总发生率为2.7%(594例)。作者认为该技术对轻中度患者微创、安全、有效,但需随机对照试验与标准手术直接比较。
要点
- 自体脂肪移植治疗腭咽闭合不全的汇总并发症发生率为2.7%(594例)。
- 七项研究的感知言语评估评分显示术后显著且持续改善。
- 患者选择标准、诊断方法和结局指标存在变异,需随机对照试验。
核心结论
- 自体脂肪移植已成为治疗轻中度腭咽闭合不全的微创、安全且有效的方法。
- 由于患者选择标准、诊断方式和结局测量存在变异,仍面临挑战。
- 本综述强调需要随机对照试验将自体脂肪移植与标准手术干预直接比较,以提供更确凿的临床疗效证据。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索五个电子数据库,时间范围为2013至2023年。
- 初检获得233项研究,其中20项符合纳入标准(以脂肪注射作为腭咽闭合不全治疗、在人类受试者中开展、脂肪注射时未附加其他手术操作)。
- 提取内容包括患者与手术干预特征、感知言语评估评分、间隙大小、鼻音测量和并发症。
主要发现
- 大多数患者有腭裂病史(78.2%),鼻内镜是观察腭咽门缺损的常用方法。
- 脂肪采集主要来自腹部(64.3%),各研究平均注射量为6.3 mL。
- 七项研究的感知言语评估评分分析显示术后显著且持续改善。
- 四项研究的间隙大小评分分析显示术前与术后存在相似差异。
- 17项研究报告并发症,594例中汇总并发症发生率为2.7%。
局限性
- 患者选择标准、诊断方式和结局测量存在变异。
- 需要随机对照试验将自体脂肪移植与标准手术干预直接比较,以提供更确凿的临床疗效证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Velopharyngeal insufficiency (VPI) is a condition characterized by incomplete separation of the oral and nasal cavities during speech production, thereby leading to speech abnormalities and audible nasal emissions. Subsequently, this adversely impacts communication and potentially interpersonal social interactions. Autologous fat grafting (AFG) to the velopharynx, a minimally invasive technique, aims to improve oronasal separation by providing bulk and advancing the posterior pharyngeal wall toward the soft palate. Despite its potential, the relative novelty of AFG in treating VPI has resulted in reporting of inconsistent indications, varied surgical techniques, and mixed outcomes across existing literature. METHODS: This systemic review examined the evidence of AFG for VPI treatment over the past decade (2013-2023). A thorough search across five electronic databases yielded 233 studies, with 20 meeting the inclusion criteria (e.g., utilized fat injection as their selected VPI treatment, conducted study in human subjects, did not perform additional surgical procedure at time of fat injection). Selected studies encompassed patient and surgical intervention characteristics, perceptual speech assessment (PSA) scores, gap sizes, nasalance measurements, and complications. RESULTS: The majority of patients had a prior cleft palate diagnosis (78.2%), in which nasoendoscopy was the prevalent method for visualizing the velopharyngeal port defect. Fat harvesting predominantly occurred from the abdomen (64.3%), with an average injection volume of 6.3 mL across studies. PSA and subjective gap size scores were consistently higher preoperatively than postoperatively. PSA score analysis from seven studies revealed significant and sustained improvements postoperatively. Gap size score analysis from four studies demonstrated similar preoperative and postoperative differences. Complications were reported in 17 studies, yielding a 2.7% summative complication rate among 594 cases. CONCLUSIONS: Autologous fat grafting has emerged as a minimally invasive, safe, and effective treatment for mild to moderate VPI. However, challenges remain because of variability in patient selection criteria, diagnostic modalities, and outcome measurements. This review underscores the need for randomized control trials to directly compare AFG with standard-of-care surgical interventions, providing more conclusive evidence of its clinical efficacy.
引用
- Mirsky NA, Slavin BV, Sheinberg DS, et al. An Evaluation of Autologous Fat Injection as a Treatment for Velopharyngeal Insufficiency: A Review and Integrated Data Analysis. Ann Plast Surg. 2024. PMID: 38775371. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000003971
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。