面向儿科烧伤科医护人员的数字化创伤知情教育干预的实施结局:混合方法过程评估
本研究对面向儿科烧伤门诊医护人员的互动网络培训「Responsive CARE」开展混合方法过程评估,使用CFIR框架和逻辑模型考察可行性。13名医护人员完成平均65%内容,访谈提炼四个主题;初步效果数据纳入177名参与者,干预前后疼痛、困扰及每患者住院费用无显著差异。
要点
- 13名医护人员完成平均65%(范围36%至88%)的可用内容,采纳率低于预期。
- 访谈识别四个影响可行性与可接受性的主题,涉及创伤知情视角与系统限制。
- 177名参与者的初步效果数据显示干预前后疼痛、困扰及每患者住院费用无显著差异。
核心结论
- 由于采纳率和保真度低于预期,逻辑模型中的因果假设无法完全检验。
- 干预前后疼痛、困扰及每患者住院费用组间无显著差异。
- 未来实施策略应包括组织支持,以保持创伤知情视角并将创伤知情原则纳入医疗模式。
- 尽管共同设计了以利益相关者参与为重点的培训与实施方法,仍需对干预和实施策略进行调整以促进采纳,凸显改变临床医生行为的复杂性。
研究设计与样本
- 采用混合方法过程评估,与「Responsive CARE」的初步有效性研究并行开展。
- 过程评估使用实施研究整合框架(CFIR)和逻辑模型,考察干预与实施策略的可行性。
- 有效性研究采用前测-后测设计,评估对儿童疼痛、困扰及费用的影响。
- 对象为向门诊烧伤服务就诊儿童及照护者提供照护的医护人员(含高级管理者),以及3个月对照期或3个月干预期内更换烧伤敷料或进行烧伤瘢痕管理的儿童及照护者。
主要发现
- 13名(预期入组50名)医护人员(均为女性)完成平均65%(范围36%至88%)的可用内容,儿科烧伤医院门诊照护平均经验10年(SD=11)。
- 完成25次半结构化访谈,包括医护人员(21名女性)和14名照护者(11名女性)。
- 识别四个影响干预可行性与可接受性的主题:1)保持创伤知情视角;2)纳入创伤知情照护的方式;3)在系统限制内工作;4)做到创伤知情。
- 初步有效性数据纳入177名参与者,中位年龄2岁,中位烧伤总面积1%。
- 干预前后疼痛、困扰及每患者住院费用组间无显著差异。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为未来实施策略应包括组织支持,以保持创伤知情视角并将创伤知情原则纳入医疗模式。
- 作者指出需对干预和实施策略进行调整以促进采纳,凸显改变临床医生行为的复杂性。
局限性
- 由于采纳率和保真度低于预期,逻辑模型中的因果假设无法完全检验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Trauma-informed care practices are associated with a culture of safety following traumatic experiences, including medical trauma. An interactive, web-based training package ('Responsive CARE') was developed for voluntary uptake by paediatric burns health professionals to increase staff knowledge about trauma-informed practice. This paper reports on a mixed methods process evaluation conducted alongside a preliminary effectiveness study of 'Responsive CARE'. The process evaluation was conducted using The Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR) and a logic model, to examine feasibility of both the intervention and implementation strategy. Health practitioners (including senior managers) delivering care to children and caregivers attending an outpatient burns service were eligible to enrol in 'Responsive CARE'. Qualitative interview data and quantitative metadata were used to evaluate the implementation outcomes (adoption, acceptability, fidelity, feasibility and preliminary effectiveness). Children and caregivers attending an outpatient service for change of burn wound dressing or burn scar management during the 3-month control or 3-month intervention period were eligible to enrol in the effectiveness study. The impact on child pain and distress, as well as cost, was investigated using a pretest-posttest design. Thirteen (from anticipated 50 enrolled) health professionals (all female) with mean 10 years (SD=11) of experience with paediatric burns hospital-based outpatient care completed an average of 65% (range 36% to 88%) of available content. Twenty-five semi-structured interviews were completed with health practitioners (21 female) and with 14 caregivers (11 female). Four themes were identified as influencing feasibility and acceptability of the intervention: 1) Keeping a trauma-informed lens; 2) Ways of incorporating trauma-informed care; 3) Working within system constraints; and 4) Being trauma-informed. Preliminary effectiveness data included 177 participants (median age 2 years, and median total body surface area burn 1%). Causal assumptions within the logic model were unable to be fully tested, secondary to lower-than-expected adoption and fidelity. We found no significant difference for pain, distress and per-patient hospital care costs between groups (pre- and post-intervention). Future implementation strategies should include organizational support to keep a trauma-informed lens and to incorporate trauma-informed principles within a medical model of care. Despite efforts to co-design a staff education intervention and implementation approach focused on stakeholder engagement, adaptations are indicated to both the intervention and implementation strategies to promote uptake highlighting the complexity of changing clinician behaviours.
引用
- Simons M, Harvey G, McMillan L, et al. Implementation outcomes of a digital, trauma-informed care, educational intervention targeting health professionals in a paediatric burns setting: A mixed methods process evaluation. Burns. 2024. PMID: 38664169. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2024.03.032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。