文献速递美容整形

整形外科住院医师选拔标准更新:项目主任与副主任调查

Update on the Selection Criteria of Plastic Surgery Residents: A Survey of Program Directors and Associate Program Directors.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Plast Surg · 2024-02-14

本研究通过匿名电子问卷调查171名整形与重建外科住院医师项目主任及副主任,评估现行选拔标准。44名(应答率25.7%)完成调查。结果显示,有USMLE分数门槛的16个项目(36.4%)中,7个(43.8%)报告230-239分范围,6个(37.5%)报告240-249分范围;48.8%受访者认为第2步分数将替代第1步分数,推荐信内容被视为权重增加最大的标准(66.7%)。

要点

  • 有USMLE分数门槛的16个项目(36.4%)中,7个(43.8%)报告230-239分范围,6个(37.5%)报告240-249分范围。
  • 48.8%受访者认为第2步分数将替代第1步分数用于评估。
  • 推荐信内容被视为权重增加最大的标准(66.7%),学术标准前三位为推荐信内容、临床成绩、推荐信作者。

核心结论

  • 整形与重建外科住院医师申请竞争激烈,Alpha Omega Alpha会员资格重要性似乎下降,而USMLE分数门槛有所提高;随着第1步评分体系变化,项目主任与副主任将更依赖第2步分数和推荐信内容。

研究设计与样本

  • 匿名12项电子问卷调查,通过Alchemer发送给171名整形与重建外科住院医师项目主任和副主任,收集完整回答并用RStudio(版本1.3.109)进行汇总统计和多变量逻辑回归分析。
  • 共44名(应答率25.7%)项目主任和副主任完成调查。

主要发现

  • 在16个(36.4%)设有USMLE分数门槛的项目中,7个(43.8%)报告范围为230至239分,6个(37.5%)报告范围为240至249分。
  • 多数受访者(48.8%)认为第2步分数将在评估标准方面取代第1步分数,推荐信内容被选为权重增加最大的标准(66.7%)。
  • 27.3%的项目要求在面试时提供第2步分数。
  • 学术标准按重要性递减前三位为推荐信内容、临床成绩和推荐信作者;非学术标准前三位为subinternship表现、成熟度和面试表现。

关键数值与推荐

  • 有USMLE分数门槛的16个项目(36.4%)中,7个(43.8%)报告230-239分范围,6个(37.5%)报告240-249分范围。
  • 48.8%受访者认为第2步分数将替代第1步分数用于评估。
  • 推荐信内容被视为权重增加最大的标准(66.7%)。
  • 27.3%的项目要求在面试时提供第2步分数。
  • 学术标准重要性前三位:推荐信内容、临床成绩、推荐信作者;非学术标准前三位:subinternship表现、成熟度、面试表现。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Plastic and reconstructive surgery (PRS) is recognized as a highly competitive specialty. Since the first assessment of resident selection criteria in 2007, PRS residency programs have adopted holistic review processes and adapted to changes such as a decline in medical schools participating in the Alpha Omega Alpha Honor Medical Society as well as the recent transition to pass/fail grading for the United States Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) step 1 examination (Schultz et al. Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open . 2020;8:e2892; Tadisina et al. Plast Reconstr Surg . 2017;139:330e-331e). This study was devised to evaluate current PRS residency criteria in light of these changes. METHODS: An anonymous, 12-item, electronic survey was generated and distributed using Alchemer. An email was sent to 171 program directors (PDs) and associate program directors (APDs) of PRS residency programs. Survey questions were developed to collect data regarding respondent demographics and their desired criteria when assessing residency applicants. Complete responses were collected and analyzed with summary statistics and multivariate logistic regression using RStudio (version 1.3.109). RESULTS: In total, 44 (25.7% response rate) of the 171 PDs and APDs completed the survey. Of the 16 programs (36.4%) with a USMLE cutoff score, 7 (43.8%) reported a range of 230 to 239 and 6 (37.5%) reported a range of 240 to 249. Without a score for step 1, the majority (48.8%) of respondents believe that step 2 scores will replace step 1 scores in terms of assessment criteria, and the content of recommendation letters was selected as the criterion with the greatest increase in weight (66.7%). In addition, 27.3% of programs require a step 2 score at the time of interview. The top 3 academic criteria in order of decreasing importance were the content of recommendation letters, clinical grades, and letter writers, whereas the top 3 nonacademic criteria were subinternship performance, maturity, and interview performance. CONCLUSIONS: Plastic and reconstructive surgery remains a highly competitive specialty for residency applicants. Our findings suggest that Alpha Omega Alpha membership remains diminished in importance, whereas USMLE cutoff scores have increased. With recent changes in the step 1 grading system, PDs and APDs will rely more heavily on step 2 scores and the content of recommendation letters.

来源:Ann Plast Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Asghari A, Hines E, Mocharnuk J, et al. Update on the Selection Criteria of Plastic Surgery Residents: A Survey of Program Directors and Associate Program Directors. Ann Plast Surg. 2024. PMID: 38369381. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000003801

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。