乳房再造网络资源中的多样性:患者看到了什么?
本研究分析谷歌搜索「乳房再造」前10个网站及前400张含人体皮肤照片/图形的图片,共471张图像,按内容、肤色和体型分类。图像以「术前/术后」为主(43.9%),90.7%为「白色」肤色、73.0%为「瘦削」体型;「术前/术后」图像中「非白色」肤色占比最高(35.3%),且更可能展示「丰满」体型女性(p < 0.0001)。结论认为网络资源未反映寻求再造的患者人群。
要点
- 共分析471张图像,43.9%为「术前/术后」类,90.7%为「白色」肤色,73.0%为「瘦削」体型。
- 「术前/术后」图像中「非白色」肤色占比最高(35.3%),且更可能展示「丰满」体型女性(p < 0.0001)。
- 作者认为网络图像资源未反映寻求乳房再造的患者人群,改善多样性可能使患者期望与术后结果更一致。
核心结论
- 乳房再造网络资源未能反映寻求再造的患者人群。
- 改善网络图像资源的多样性既能更好地代表多元患者人群,也能使患者期望与术后结果更一致,可能提高患者满意度。
研究设计与样本
- 分析谷歌搜索短语「乳房再造」排名前10的网站及前400张含人体皮肤照片/图形的图片。
- 共471张图像,按内容分为「术前/术后」、「手术/解剖」、「分步」或「以乳房为中心的图库图片」。
- 图像对象按Fitzpatrick量表肤色分为「白色」或「非白色」,按体型分为「瘦削」或「丰满」。
主要发现
- 图像以「术前/术后」为主(43.9%),其次为「以乳房为中心的图库图片」(27.4%)、「手术/解剖」(24.2%)和「分步」(4.5%)。
- 多数图像为「白色」肤色(90.7%)和「瘦削」体型(73.0%)。
- 「术前/术后」图像较其他内容类别更可能展示「丰满」体型女性(p < 0.0001),且「非白色」肤色占比最高(35.3%)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Online resources are commonly used by patients to obtain information on breast reconstruction. Despite the key role of these resources in patient decision-making, their visual content has not yet been evaluated. This study sought to 1) characterize the presence and content of visual aids in online patient education breast reconstruction resources and 2) determine if the women represented in these visual aids reflect the breast reconstruction patient population in the United States. METHODS: The top 10 Google websites and the first 400 Google Images containing photographs/graphics depicting human skin for the search phrase "breast reconstruction" were analyzed. Images were categorized by content as "Before/After," "Surgical/Anatomical," "Step-by-Step," or "Breast-Centric Stock Images." Image subjects were classified by skin tone into "White" or "Non-White" using the Fitzpatrick scale and by body type into "Lean" or "Full-Figured." RESULTS: In total, 471 images were analyzed. These were predominantly "Before/After" images (43.9%), followed by "Breast-Centric Stock Images" (27.4%), "Surgical/Anatomical" (24.2%), and "Step-by-Step" (4.5%). The majority of all images depicted "White" skin types (90.7%) and "Lean" body types (73.0%). "Before/After" images were more likely to show "Full-Figured" women than the other content categories (p < 0.0001) and had the highest percentage of "Non-White" skin types (35.3%). CONCLUSIONS: Our findings demonstrate that breast reconstruction online resources are not reflective of the patient population seeking reconstruction. Improving the diversity of online image resources can both better represent our diverse patient population as well as better align patient expectations with postoperative outcomes, likely improving patient satisfaction.
引用
- Lee E, Yesantharao P, Long C, et al. Diversity in online resources for breast reconstruction: What do patients see? J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2023. PMID: 38199217. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2023.09.028
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。