探索全球烧伤登记系统的异同:数据字典比较研究结果
该研究邀请全球烧伤登记系统保管者共享数据字典,比较13个登记系统的纳入排除标准、变量数量与主题分类,并对年龄、损伤时间、意图、机制、吸入性损伤、感染和患者死亡等概念的定义与测量方法进行对比。结果显示登记系统间存在共性与差异,共性有助于未来数据合并比较,差异可能引入选择偏倚和测量偏倚。作者建议制定国际烧伤最低数据集通用数据元素,包括标准定义和测量方法。
要点
- 13个烧伤登记系统参与,各系统纳入标准不同,每系统变量数中位数94个(范围28-890),其中24%(范围4.8-100%)为必采集变量。
- 识别出6个主题和41个子主题;年龄和损伤时间的数据采集相似,意图、机制、吸入性损伤、感染和患者死亡的测量变异较大。
- 作者建议制定国际烧伤最低数据集通用数据元素,包括标准定义和测量方法,作为实现烧伤登记数据共享的下一步。
核心结论
- 登记系统间存在共性也有差异,共性有助于未来数据合并比较,差异可能引入选择偏倚和测量偏倚,需在促进烧伤登记数据共享的策略中加以解决。
- 作者推荐制定用于国际烧伤最低数据集的通用数据元素,包括标准定义和测量方法,作为实现烧伤登记数据共享的下一步。
研究设计与样本
- 邀请登记系统保管者参与并共享数据字典,比较纳入和排除标准以了解各登记系统人群,计算唯一变量数量的描述性统计,将变量分类为主题,并对样本登记概念比较定义、方法、测量时机和回答选项。
- 13个烧伤登记系统参与研究。
主要发现
- 各登记系统纳入标准不同;每系统变量数中位数为94(范围28-890),其中24%(范围4.8-100%)为必采集变量。
- 识别出6个主题(患者信息、入院详情、损伤、住院、门诊、其他)和41个子主题。
- 年龄和损伤时间的登记概念在数据采集上显示相似性;意图、机制、吸入性损伤、感染和患者死亡的测量变异较大。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Pooling and comparing data from the existing global network of burn registers represents a powerful, yet untapped, opportunity to improve burn prevention and care. There have been no studies investigating whether registers are sufficiently similar to allow data comparisons. It is also not known what differences exist that could bias analyses. Understanding this information is essential prior to any future data sharing. The aim of this project was to compare the variables collected in countrywide and intercountry burn registers to understand their similarities and differences. METHODS: Register custodians were invited to participate and share their data dictionaries. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were compared to understand each register population. Descriptive statistics were calculated for the number of unique variables. Variables were classified into themes. Definition, method, timing of measurement, and response options were compared for a sample of register concepts. RESULTS: 13 burn registries participated in the study. Inclusion criteria varied between registers. Median number of variables per register was 94 (range 28 - 890), of which 24% (range 4.8 - 100%) were required to be collected. Six themes (patient information, admission details, injury, inpatient, outpatient, other) and 41 subthemes were identified. Register concepts of age and timing of injury show similarities in data collection. Intent, mechanism, inhalational injury, infection, and patient death show greater variation in measurement. CONCLUSIONS: We found some commonalities between registers and some differences. Commonalities would assist in any future efforts to pool and compare data between registers. Differences between registers could introduce selection and measurement bias, which needs to be addressed in any strategy aiming to facilitate burn register data sharing. We recommend the development of common data elements used in an international minimum data set for burn injuries, including standard definitions and methods of measurement, as the next step in achieving burn register data sharing.
引用
- Bebbington E, Miles J, Young A, et al. Exploring the similarities and differences of burn registers globally: Results from a data dictionary comparison study. Burns. 2024. PMID: 38267291. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2024.01.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。