颅外鼻皮样囊肿的手术方式选择:一项Meta分析
该系统综述纳入1958年至2020年间43项研究、439例鼻皮样囊肿病例,按手术方式行单臂Meta分析估计复发和复合不良事件风险。结果显示外切口复发(1.78%)和复合不良事件(4.94%)汇总发生率最低,鼻整形术较高(分别为4.81%和8.32%),经鼻内镜最高(复发7.89%)。作者认为外切口患者不良事件发生率最低,未来需设计良好的前瞻性研究比较各术式的不良事件率和美容效果。
要点
- 外切口汇总复发发生率1.78%(95%CI 0.57%, 3.65%),复合不良事件4.94%(95%CI 2.72%, 7.77%)。
- 鼻整形术汇总复发发生率4.81%(95%CI 0.91%, 11.6%),复合不良事件8.32%(95%CI 2.77%, 16.5%)。
- 经鼻内镜汇总复发发生率7.89%(95%CI 0%, 28.9%),为唯一报告的不良事件。
核心结论
- 作者认为,接受外切口切除鼻皮样囊肿的患者不良事件发生率最低,鼻整形术患者较高,经鼻内镜患者最高。
- 作者提出,未来应开展设计良好的前瞻性研究,比较不同手术方式的不良事件率和美容效果。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索鼻中线皮样囊肿外科治疗的研究,按手术方式行单臂Meta分析,估计复发和复合不良事件(复发、翻修、感染或再入院)的汇总风险。
- 共纳入43项符合条件的研究,发表于1958年至2020年间,报告439例鼻皮样囊肿。
- 治疗方式包括外切口(25项研究)、鼻整形术(15项研究)和经鼻内镜(5项研究)。
- 据作者所知,尚无研究比较不同手术方式之间的结局发生率。
主要发现
- 外切口汇总复发发生率1.78%(95%CI: 0.57%, 3.65%),复合不良事件汇总发生率4.94%(95%CI: 2.72%, 7.77%)。
- 鼻整形术汇总复发发生率4.81%(95%CI: 0.91%, 11.6%),复合不良事件汇总发生率8.32%(95%CI: 2.77%, 16.5%)。
- 经鼻内镜汇总复发发生率7.89%(95%CI: 0%, 28.9%),为唯一报告的不良事件。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 据作者所知,尚无研究比较不同手术方式之间的结局发生率。
- 作者提出,未来应开展设计良好的前瞻性研究,比较不同手术方式的不良事件率和美容效果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Nasal dermoid cysts are surgically treated using external incision, open rhinoplasty, transnasal endoscopy, or combined approaches. It is unclear how these approaches differ with regard to the incidence of adverse events. METHODS: We conducted a systematic review of studies on the surgical management of midline nasal dermoids. Following data abstraction, we carried out a series of single-arm meta-analyses to estimate summary risks of recurrence and combined adverse events (recurrence, revision, infection, or readmission) according to the surgical approach. RESULTS: Forty-three eligible studies published between 1958 and 2020 reported on 439 cases of nasal dermoid cysts. Treatment approaches included external incision (25 studies), rhinoplasty (15 studies), and transnasal endoscopy (5 studies). To our knowledge, no study has compared outcome incidence between the surgical approaches. External incision had the lowest summary incidence of both recurrence (1.78% [95% CI: 0.57%, 3.65%]) and combined adverse events (4.94% [95% CI: 2.72%, 7.77%]). Rhinoplasty had a higher incidence of recurrence (4.81% [95% CI: 0.91%, 11.6%]) and combined adverse events (8.32% [95% CI: 2.77%, 16.5%]), and transnasal endoscopy had the highest incidence of recurrence (the only reported adverse event; 7.89% [95% CI: 0%, 28.9%]). CONCLUSION: Our results suggest that the incidence of adverse events was lowest among patients who were subjected to external incision for nasal dermoid removal. Incidence was higher for patients who underwent rhinoplasty and the highest for patients who underwent transnasal endoscopy. Future work on this topic should include well-designed prospective studies that compare rates of adverse events and cosmetic outcomes between surgical approaches.
引用
- Kohan J, McGee SA, Self Q, et al. Operative options for extracranial nasal dermoid cysts: A meta-analysis. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2023. PMID: 37983980. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2023.10.114
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。