全球视角下大面积关节烧伤挛缩危险因素的文献综述
本文广泛综述高收入国家(HIC)与中低收入国家(LMIC)关于烧伤后关节挛缩危险因素的文献,纳入94篇(截至2019年6月)及后续8篇(截至2022年3月),其中76%来自HIC。仅15项研究对挛缩危险因素进行了统计学比较,LMIC文献还提及社会经济与医疗体系因素。综述指出许多公认危险因素缺乏稳健证据,需更多研究以制定符合情境的预防策略。
要点
- LMIC文献关注社会经济与医疗体系因素,而HIC文献很少考虑这些因素。
- 方法学问题包括挛缩定义、研究人群、照护标准、关节选择及评估时机与性质差异。
核心结论
- 本综述首次汇总HIC与LMIC烧伤挛缩危险因素证据,发现许多公认危险因素缺乏稳健证据。
- LMIC中普遍医疗供给缺乏、专科烧伤照护稀缺且难以获取,社会经济因素对挛缩结局的影响可能比特定烧伤治疗更直接。
- 需更多工作以全面理解不同情境下危险因素的相对影响,从而制定情境适宜的挛缩预防策略。
主要发现
- 多数出版物为描述性研究(HIC 4篇,LMIC 9篇)或引用推定危险因素的论文(HIC 37篇,LMIC 10篇)。
- 17篇出版物(均来自HIC)报告个体非手术治疗干预的效果,结果常相互矛盾。
- 两项已发表的系统综述强调现有证据质量差。
- 仅15项研究(其中3项来自LMIC)通过结局统计学比较探讨潜在挛缩危险因素;显著发现包括人口学、烧伤、合并症和治疗相关危险因素。
- LMIC论文将社会经济和医疗体系因素列为挛缩潜在风险,而HIC出版物很少考虑这些因素。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 两项已发表的系统综述强调现有证据质量差。
- 方法学问题包括挛缩定义、研究人群、照护标准、纳入关节以及挛缩评估时机和性质的差异。
- 许多公认危险因素缺乏稳健证据,需更多工作以全面理解不同情境下危险因素的相对影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Contractures are a frequent consequence of burn injuries, yet our knowledge of associated risk factors is limited. This paper provides an extensive review of relevant literature from both High-Income Countries (HICs) and Low-Middle Income Countries (LMICs). Ninety-four papers (up to June 2019) and eight subsequent publications (up to March 2022) were included, 76% of which were from HICs. The majority of publications were either descriptive studies (4 from HICs, 9 from LMICs) or papers citing putative risk factors (37 from HICs, 10 from LMICs). Seventeen publications (all from HICs) reported on the effects of individual non-surgical therapeutic interventions, often with conflicting results. Two published systematic reviews emphasised the poor quality of evidence available. Only fifteen studies (3 from LMICs) examined potential contracture risk factors with statistical comparisons of outcomes; significant findings from these included demographic, burn, comorbidities, and treatment risk factors. LMIC papers included socioeconomic and healthcare system factors as potential risks for contracture; these were rarely considered in HIC publications. Methodological issues identified from this review of literature included differences in contracture definitions, populations studied, standards of care, joints included and the timing and nature of contracture assessments.This review is the first to collate existing knowledge on risk factors for burn contractures from both HIC and LMIC settings, revealing a surprising lack of robust evidence for many accepted risk factors. In LMICs, where burns are particularly common, universal health provision is lacking and specialist burn care is both scarce and difficult to access; consequently, socioeconomic factors may have more immediate impact on contracture outcomes than specific burn treatments or therapies. Much more work is indicated to fully understand the relative impacts of risk factors in different settings so that context-appropriate contracture prevention strategies can be developed.
引用
- Fanstone R, Price P. Global perspectives on risk factors for major joint burn contractures: A literature review. Burns. 2023. PMID: 37977897. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2023.09.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。