中低收入国家烧伤挛缩风险因素与测量:临床视角
该研究指出缺乏关于烧伤挛缩形成风险因素的高质量已发表证据,且绝大多数研究来自高收入国家。为补充文献,研究者对17名具有中低收入国家经验的烧伤护理专业人员进行了半结构化访谈,共报告90项风险因素,但无人提供标准化的测量系统或挛缩的操作性定义。
要点
- 访谈17名中低收入国家烧伤护理专业人员,报告90项烧伤挛缩风险因素。
- 最常被提及的风险因素为缺乏夹板固定、缺乏物理治疗、缺乏早期切除和皮肤移植、低社会经济地位及存在感染。
- 参与者均能识别挛缩,但无人提供标准化测量系统或操作性定义,凸显统一诊断分类方法的需求。
核心结论
- 烧伤护理专业人员对本国人群烧伤挛缩形成风险因素拥有丰富但尚未被文献充分探索的经验与知识。
- 临床医生对烧伤挛缩诊断和测量的差异凸显需要一种商定的、标准化、简单且易于重复的诊断和分类方法。
研究设计与样本
- 对17名具有中低收入国家经验的烧伤护理专业人员进行半结构化访谈,其中13名烧伤外科医生和4名治疗师。
- 参与者平均烧伤护理经验为13年,代表加纳、埃塞俄比亚、马拉维、尼日利亚、南非、尼泊尔和印度。
主要发现
- 参与者共报告90项风险因素,按主题整理为:非烧伤个体因素13项、烧伤损伤因素14项、家庭和社区因素9项、治疗因素18项、并发症2项、医疗系统能力因素19项、社会和环境因素12项。
- 最常被提及的五项风险因素为缺乏夹板固定、缺乏物理治疗、缺乏早期切除和皮肤移植、低社会经济地位以及存在感染。
- 参与者均表示能识别挛缩,但无人提供标准化的测量系统或挛缩的操作性定义。
局限性
- 原文指出缺乏关于烧伤挛缩形成风险因素的高质量已发表证据,绝大多数研究来自高收入国家。
- 原文指出参与者强调的许多风险因素尚未在文献中被探索。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
We find a lack of high-quality published evidence on risk factors for burn contracture formation. The vast majority of research is from High Income Countries (HICs), where many potential risk factors are controlled for by standardised and high-quality healthcare systems. To augment the published literature, burn care professionals with Low Middle Income Countries (LMICs) experience were interviewed for their opinion on risk factors for burn contracture formation. Participants were also asked for their views on identification and measurement of contracture. Seventeen semi-structured interviews were conducted (13 burn surgeons and 4 therapists). The average length of experience in burn-care was 13 years. Participants represented Ghana, Ethiopia, Malawi, Nigeria, South Africa, Nepal, and India. Participants reported ninety risk factors. Risk factors were later collated according to topic: Non burn individual factors (n = 13), Burn injury factors (n = 14), Family and community factors (n = 9), Treatment factors (n = 18), Complications (n = 2), Healthcare capacity factors (n = 19) and Societal and environmental factors (n = 12). The top five most frequently cited risk factors were lack of splinting, lack of physiotherapy, lack of early excision and skin grafting, low socioeconomic status and presence of infection. Although participants had no doubts that they could recognise a contracture, none provided a standardised system of measurement or an operational definition of contracture. Burn care professionals have a wealth of experience and untapped knowledge of risk factors for burn contracture formation in their own population base, but many of the risk factors highlighted by participants have not yet been explored in the literature. Variations in clinicians' diagnosis and measurement of a burn contracture underscores the need for an agreed, standardised, simple and easily reproducible method of diagnosing and classifying burn contractures.
引用
- Fanstone R, Price P. Burn contracture risk factors and measurement in low-middle income countries: A clinical perspective. Burns. 2023. PMID: 37985269. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2023.09.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。