如何在显微外科与超显微外科中测量血管口径?三种临床适用方法的计量学研究
该计量学研究由六名评估者用标准刻度尺、Shinwa®测微尺和ImageJ®软件分别测量15根三种隐藏直径(1.2 mm、0.8 mm、0.6 mm)的导管,评估组内、组间及方法间组内相关系数(ICC)及其95%CI。ImageJ®软件组内ICC为0.97[0.94-0.99]、组间ICC为0.95[0.89-0.98],可靠性最佳;标准刻度尺组间ICC为0.51[0.23-0.93],可靠性最差。
要点
- ImageJ®软件测量血管口径的组内ICC 0.97、组间ICC 0.95,可靠性最佳。
- Shinwa®测微尺组间ICC 0.87,可靠性可接受但需购置设备。
- 标准刻度尺组间ICC 0.51,为三种方法中可靠性最差。
核心结论
- 本研究客观证明,术中摄影结合免费计算机软件(ImageJ®)测量显微与超显微外科血管口径具有很高的准确性和可靠性。
- 标准刻度尺是最不可靠的测量方法;Shinwa®测微尺可靠性可接受但需购买设备;ImageJ®软件可靠性最佳,似乎是最可靠的方法。
研究设计与样本
- 计量学研究,由六名评估者测量15根三种不同隐藏直径(1.2 mm、0.8 mm、0.6 mm)的导管。
- 三种临床适用测量方法为:标准刻度尺、Shinwa®测微尺、基于照片的ImageJ®软件。
- 通过组内、组间和方法间相关系数(组内相关系数ICC的变体)及ICC的95%CI分析评估测量的准确性和可靠性。
主要发现
- 组内ICC:标准刻度尺0.81[0.65-0.93],Shinwa®测微尺0.86[0.67-0.96],ImageJ®软件0.97[0.94-0.99]。
- 组间ICC:标准刻度尺0.51[0.23-0.93],Shinwa®测微尺0.87[0.75-0.95],ImageJ®软件0.95[0.89-0.98]。
- 标准刻度尺是最不可靠的测量方法,Shinwa®测微尺可靠性可接受但需购买设备,ImageJ®软件可靠性最佳。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: The microsurgical literature reports the vascular calibers of the vessels studied even though the method of measurement of these vessels is very rarely reported. MATERIAL AND METHOD: We performed a metrological study evaluating three methods to measure the external calibers of catheters corresponding to microsurgical and super-microsurgical vessels (1.2 mm, 0.8 mm, and 0.6 mm). Six evaluators measured 15 catheters of three different hidden diameters by each of the three methods applicable in clinical practice: standard graduated ruler, Shinwa® micrometric ruler, and ImageJ® software from a photograph. Accuracy and reliability of the measurements were assessed by studying the inter- and intra-rater and inter-method coefficients (variants of the intra-class coefficient (ICC)) and analysis of the IC95% of the ICCs. RESULTS: Intra class correlation ICC "intra-rater" coefficient finds for the standard rule 0.81 [0.65-0.93], Shinwa® rule 0.86 [0.67-0.96], and for the ImageJ® software 0.97 [0.94-0.99]. The "Inter-rater" ICC shows respectively the coefficient 0.51 [0.23 and max 0.93], 0.87 [0.75-0.95], and 0.95 [0.89-0.98]. It appears that the graduated decimeter is the least reliable method of measurement, the Shinwa® ruler presents acceptable reliability but requires the purchase of equipment. The reliability of ImageJ® software is the best and appears to be the most reliable method. CONCLUSION: Our original study, with no equivalent in the scientific literature, demonstrates objectively the great accuracy and reliability of a method of measurement of vascular calibers in micro and super microsurgery using intraoperative photography and the use of free computer software.
引用
- Lancien U, Goronflot T, Verdier J, et al. How to measure vessel caliber in microsurgery and super-microsurgery? Metrological study of three methods applicable in clinical practice. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2023. PMID: 37271002. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2023.05.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。