文献速递美容整形

鼻整形都去哪儿了?呼吁学术整形外科医生趁早着力增加鼻整形手术量

Where Have All the Rhinoplasties Gone? A Call to Action for Academic Plastic Surgeons to Focus on Increasing Rhinoplasty Procedures Before It Is Too Late.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Plast Surg · 2023-04-17

该研究检索3家同时设有整形外科与耳鼻喉科住院医师项目的学术机构2009年1月1日至2019年12月31日的鼻整形记录,统计各专科每年手术量。结果显示各机构鼻整形总量增长27%至149%,但整形外科医生完成的鼻整形不足全部的三分之一;3个耳鼻喉科部门鼻整形量均呈统计学显著上升趋势,机构1与机构2整形外科呈下降趋势但无统计学显著性,机构3整形外科呈统计学显著上升趋势。作者认为耳鼻喉科在多所学术机构中完成大多数鼻整形,令人担忧整形外科培训,学术整形外科医生须着力增加鼻整形例数。

要点

  • 3家学术机构鼻整形总量增长率为27%至149%,整形外科医生完成不足全部鼻整形的三分之一。
  • 2009年整形外科完成鼻整形比例在机构1、2、3分别为10%、22%、18%,2019年分别为5%、12%、27%。
  • 3个耳鼻喉科部门鼻整形量均呈统计学显著上升趋势;机构3整形外科亦呈统计学显著上升趋势。

核心结论

  • 耳鼻喉科在若干学术机构中完成大多数鼻整形,这一现象令人担忧整形外科受训者的教育。
  • 学术整形外科医生必须着力增加所完成的鼻整形例数,以充分培训住院医师掌握这一核心手术。
  • 作者认为若现在不把鼻整形列为优先事项,该手术可能沦为历史性手术,而不再是整形外科医生手术武器库中的重要技能。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入3家同时设有整形外科与耳鼻喉科住院医师项目的学术机构,检索2009年1月1日至2019年12月31日鼻整形的现行程序术语(CPT)编码医疗记录。
  • 按专科统计各机构每年鼻整形总例数。
  • 原文未报告各机构的具体样本量与病例总数。

主要发现

  • 参与机构鼻整形量的增长率为27%至149%。
  • 在这些机构中,整形外科医生完成的鼻整形不足全部鼻整形例数的三分之一。
  • 2009年整形外科医生完成的鼻整形比例在机构1为10%、机构2为22%、机构3为18%;2019年分别为5%、12%、27%。
  • 3个耳鼻喉科部门的鼻整形量均呈统计学显著上升趋势。
  • 机构1与机构2的整形外科部门鼻整形量呈下降趋势但无统计学显著性;机构3整形外科部门呈统计学显著上升趋势。

关键数值与推荐

  • 受训者须完成10例鼻整形以满足毕业要求,但更重要的是住院医师毕业时应具备胜任且自信地实施鼻整形的能力。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为学术整形外科医生必须着力增加所完成的鼻整形例数,以充分培训住院医师掌握这一核心手术。
  • 作者认为若现在不把鼻整形列为优先事项,该手术可能沦为历史性手术,而不再是整形外科医生手术武器库中的重要技能。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The armamentarium of a plastic surgeon is vast, consisting of an array of surgical procedures from head to toe. Unfortunately, plastic surgeons have been losing portions of their operative domain to other surgical subspecialties for years. The number of subspecialties invading our niche is bothersome, but more concerning is the fact that losing the reins of these core procedures results in less surgical exposure and competency for plastic surgery residents.Lately, in academic institutions, otolaryngologists seem to be performing most rhinoplasty procedures, resulting in fewer surgeries performed by plastic surgeons. Trainees must perform 10 rhinoplasties to fulfill graduation requirements but, more importantly, residents should graduate feeling competent and confident performing rhinoplasties. The aims of this study are to determine the number of rhinoplasties being performed at academic centers each year and to evaluate the trend with regard to which specialties are performing these procedures. METHODS: Three academic institutions with plastic surgery and otolaryngology residency programs searched medical records for rhinoplasty Current Procedural Terminology codes from January 1, 2009, to December 31, 2019. The total numbers of rhinoplasties performed each year, by each specialty, were tallied. RESULTS: Growth rate in rhinoplasty volume among participating institutions ranged from 27% to 149%. At these institutions, plastic surgeons performed less than one third of all rhinoplasties. In 2009, 10% of rhinoplasties were performed by plastic surgeons at institution 1, 22% at institution 2, and 18% at institution 3. In 2019, the volume of rhinoplasties performed by plastic surgeons was 5%, 12%, and 27%, respectively. The 3 ENT departments had statistically significant increasing trends in rhinoplasty volume. Institutions 1 and 2's plastic surgery departments showed that negative volume trends, however, were not statistically significant. Institution 3's plastic surgery department has had an increasing trend, which was statistically significant. CONCLUSIONS: Otolaryngology is performing most rhinoplasties at several academic institutions. This is concerning for the education of plastic surgery trainees. Academic plastic surgeons must focus on increasing the number of rhinoplasties performed to adequately train residents this core procedure. If rhinoplasties are not made a priority now, this surgery may become a historic operation instead of a vital skill in plastic surgeons' armamentarium.

来源:Ann Plast Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Jordan A, Tashmia A, Wang S, et al. Where Have All the Rhinoplasties Gone? A Call to Action for Academic Plastic Surgeons to Focus on Increasing Rhinoplasty Procedures Before It Is Too Late. Ann Plast Surg. 2023. PMID: 37115851. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000003531

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。