导师制能否打破学术显微外科中的玻璃天花板?一项针对显微外科专科培训女性学者的全国性调查
该研究调查了完成显微外科专科培训并在学术整形外科项目任职的女性,评估学术显微外科中女性的代表性及导师制对职业发展的影响。48名调查对象中27人参与(应答率56.3%),多数为助理教授(40.0%)或副教授(20.0%)。受访者整个培训期间平均有4.1±2.3名导师,仅28.3%的导师接受过显微外科培训,29.2%的受访者报告培训期间有女性导师。主治医师阶段获得形成性导师指导的比例最低(52.0%)。50%的受访者寻求女性导师,原因是对女性视角的渴求;未寻求女性导师者中72.7%归因于缺乏接触女性导师的途径。结论指出,女性学员找不到女性导师及主治医师阶段导师制比例低,表明当前女性导师的供给不足以满足追求学术显微外科的女性的需求,该领域存在许多个体和结构性障碍。
要点
- 48名调查对象中27人参与,应答率56.3%,多数为助理教授(40.0%)或副教授(20.0%)。
- 受访者整个培训期间平均有4.1±2.3名导师,仅28.3%的导师接受过显微外科培训。
- 29.2%的受访者报告培训期间有女性导师,主治医师阶段获得形成性导师指导的比例最低(52.0%)。
核心结论
- 女性学员找不到女性导师且主治医师阶段导师制比例低,表明当前女性导师的供给不足以满足追求学术显微外科的女性的需求,该领域存在许多个体和结构性障碍。
研究设计与样本
- 电子调查设计,旨在确定受访者在不同职业阶段(从医学生到主治医师)获得导师指导的可及性和质量。
- 调查分发给完成显微外科专科培训且当前在学术整形外科项目任职的女性。
- 48名调查对象中27人参与,应答率56.3%。
主要发现
- 多数受访者担任副教授(20.0%)或助理教授(40.0%)职位。
- 受访者整个培训期间平均有4.1±2.3名导师。
- 少数导师接受过显微外科培训(28.3%),仅29.2%的受访者报告培训期间有女性导师。
- 主治医师获得形成性导师指导的比例最低(52.0%)。
- 50%的受访者寻求女性导师,原因是渴望女性视角;未寻求女性导师者中72.7%归因于缺乏接触女性导师的途径。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The "leaky pipeline" phenomenon has caused women to remain underrepresented at higher levels of academic plastic surgery. No study has considered the availability of mentorship within any subset of academic plastic surgery. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the current representation of women in academic microsurgery and to determine the impact of mentorship on career progression. METHODS: An electronic survey was designed to determine the availability and quality of mentorship respondents received at different stages of their career (from medical student to attending physician). The survey was distributed to women who completed a microsurgery fellowship and were current faculty at an academic plastic surgery program. RESULTS: Twenty-seven of 48 survey recipients participated (56.3% response rate). Most held an associate professor (20.0%) or assistant professor (40.0%) position. Respondents had an average of 4.1 ± 2.3 mentors throughout their entire training. A minority of mentors were microsurgery trained (28.3%), and only 29.2% of respondents reported female mentorship throughout their training. Attending physicians least often received formative mentorship (52.0%). Fifty percent of respondents sought female mentors, citing that they desired female insight. Of those who did not seek female mentors, 72.7% cited a lack of access to female mentors. CONCLUSIONS: Evidenced by female trainees being unable to find female mentors and low rates of mentorship at the attending physician level, there is currently not enough capacity to meet the demand for female mentorship by women pursuing academic microsurgery. Many individual and structural barriers to quality mentorship and sponsorship exist within this field.
引用
- Abdou SA, Sharif-Askary B, Sayyed AA, et al. Can Mentorship Shatter the Glass Ceiling in Academic Microsurgery? A National Survey of Microsurgery Fellowship-Trained Women. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2023. PMID: 37075287. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000010570
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。