患者还是囚犯?囚犯的急性烧伤:伯明翰烧伤中心经验
该研究利用国际烧伤损伤数据库(iBID)识别2010年至2021年转诊的囚犯烧伤患者,分析其发生率、损伤模式与结局。共68例囚犯烧伤患者,中位年龄28.5岁,中位TBSA 3%,男性占98.5%,75%需住院,烫伤最常见(77.9%),袭击是最常见致伤原因(63.2%),18例(26.5%)接受手术,2例死亡。在计划随访的患者中,22%未参加任何预约,另有49%至少错过一次预约。作者认为应关注保护易受袭击的脆弱患者、对监狱工作人员进行烧伤预防与急救教育,并确保囚犯能够获得烧伤随访以减少长期后遗症,远程医疗等机会有助于实现这一目标。
要点
- 68例囚犯烧伤患者中位年龄28.5岁、中位TBSA 3%,男性占98.5%,75%需住院。
- 烫伤最常见(77.9%),袭击是最常见致伤原因(63.2%),18例(26.5%)接受手术,2例死亡。
- 计划随访的囚犯中22%未参加任何预约,另有49%至少错过一次预约。
核心结论
- 囚犯是具有特殊挑战的独特人群,应关注保护有受袭击风险的脆弱患者、对监狱工作人员进行烧伤预防与急救教育,并确保囚犯能够获得烧伤随访以减少长期后遗症,远程医疗等机会有助于实现这一目标。
- 作者认为远程医疗等机会有助于改善囚犯烧伤随访。
研究设计与样本
- 利用国际烧伤损伤数据库(iBID)识别2010年至2021年转诊的囚犯烧伤患者。
- 收集患者人口学资料、烧伤损伤特征与结局,并按损伤机制、治疗方式(手术/保守)、住院情况(住院/门诊)及门诊随访依从性进行分层亚组分析。
- 研究期间共68例囚犯烧伤患者。
主要发现
- 囚犯烧伤患者中位年龄28.5岁,中位TBSA 3%,男性占98.5%,需住院者占75%。
- 烫伤为最常见损伤类型(77.9%),袭击为最常见烧伤原因(63.2%)。
- 18例(26.5%)接受手术,2例死亡。
- 在计划随访的患者中,22%未参加任何预约,另有49%至少错过一次预约。
- 与接受非手术治疗的患者相比,接受手术的囚犯住院时间更长,且全部参加了门诊随访预约。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为应关注保护有受袭击风险的脆弱患者。
- 作者认为应对监狱工作人员进行烧伤预防与急救教育。
- 作者认为应确保囚犯能够获得烧伤随访以减少长期后遗症。
- 作者认为远程医疗等机会有助于实现上述目标。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Increased risk of violence and self-harm means prisoners are a vulnerable population with complex health needs. They account for a small proportion of patients with burn injuries; however, present a unique set of challenges. This study investigates the incidence, pattern and outcomes of burn injuries in prison population. Prisoners referred from 2010 to 2021 were identified using the International Burn Injury Database (iBID). Patient demographics, burn injury characteristics and outcomes were collected. Patients were then stratified based on mechanism of injury, treatment modality (surgery/conservative), hospital admission (inpatient/outpatient), and compliance with outpatient follow-up, for subgroup analyses. Sixty-eight prisoners sustained burns during the study period, with a median age of 28.5 years and TBSA of 3%. The majority were male (98.5%) and required hospital admission (75%). Scalds were the most common injury type (77.9%) and assault the most frequent cause of burns (63.2%). Eighteen patients (26.5%) underwent a surgical procedure and there were two mortalities. Of patients for whom follow-up was planned, 22% attended no appointments, with a further 49% of prisoners missing at least one appointment. Relative to patients managed nonoperatively, prisoners undergoing surgery had a longer stay and all attended outpatient follow-up appointments. Prisoners represent a unique population with exceptional challenges. Attention should be given to protecting vulnerable patients at risk of assault, education of prison staff around burn prevention and first aid, and ensuring that prisoners are able to access burns follow-up to minimize long-term sequelae. Opportunities exist to aid this such as the adoption of telemedicine.
引用
- Rafie A, Kankam HKN, Sandhu A, et al. Patient or Prisoner?: Acute Burn Injuries in Prisoners-The Birmingham Burns Centre Experience. J Burn Care Res. 2023. PMID: 37021549. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irad052
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。