唇裂手术服务的全国性低估:来自50,450例病例比较分析的证据
该研究基于美国国家手术质量改进计划儿科数据库,分析2012至2019年整形外科医生实施的69个唇裂与颅颌面手术CPT编码共50,450例。以总相对价值单位(RVU)除以总手术时间定义效率,发现颅颌面手术效率最高四分位均值为15.65±4.22 RVU/小时,唇裂手术最低四分位均值为7.39±0.98 RVU/小时(P<0.001)。作者认为RVU分配造成效率差异,唇裂手术受到不成比例的负面影响,应重新评估RVU分配以避免抑制唇裂外科治疗。
要点
- 颅颌面手术效率最高四分位均值15.65±4.22 RVU/小时,唇裂手术最低四分位均值7.39±0.98 RVU/小时(P<0.001)。
- 唇裂与颅颌面外科医生行局部皮瓣手术的效率(15.18 RVU/小时)是唇裂继发腭延长术(6.09 RVU/小时)的2.5倍。
- 作者认为当前RVU分配对唇裂手术产生不成比例的负面效率差异,应重新评估RVU分配。
核心结论
- 当前唇裂与颅颌面手术的RVU分配造成医生效率的任意差异,唇裂手术受到不成比例的负面影响。
- 作者认为应重新评估RVU分配,以避免抑制唇裂外科治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 查询美国国家手术质量改进计划儿科数据库,依据CPT编码识别2012至2019年整形外科医生实施的全部唇裂与颅颌面手术病例。
- 排除显微外科病例及病例数少于10的CPT编码,最终样本为69个CPT编码共50,450例。
- 效率定义为总RVU除以总手术时间(即RVU/小时),按CPT编码计算平均效率并排名,使用t检验按四分位比较。
主要发现
- 最高四分位中多数CPT编码为颅颌面手术,包括额面部手术(23.53%)和颅缝早闭或骨性病变的颅骨切除术(35.29%),平均效率为15.65±4.22 RVU/小时。
- 最低四分位主要由唇裂手术CPT编码组成,包括腭咽闭合不全手术(17.65%)、腭裂修复(23.53%)和唇裂鼻中隔成形术(5.88%),平均效率为7.39±0.98 RVU/小时(P<0.001)。
- 唇裂与颅颌面外科医生行局部皮瓣手术的效率为15.18 RVU/小时,是唇裂继发腭延长术(6.09 RVU/小时)的2.5倍。
关键数值与推荐
- 效率以总RVU除以总手术时间(RVU/小时)计算。
- 最高四分位平均效率为15.65±4.22 RVU/小时,最低四分位平均效率为7.39±0.98 RVU/小时,组间比较P<0.001。
- 局部皮瓣手术效率为15.18 RVU/小时,唇裂继发腭延长术效率为6.09 RVU/小时,前者为后者的2.5倍。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Relative value units (RVUs) are broadly used for billing and physician compensation; however, the accuracy of RVU assignments has not been scientifically evaluated for craniofacial surgery. The authors hypothesize that unbalanced RVU allocation creates inappropriate disparities in value among procedures performed by cleft and craniofacial surgeons. METHODS: The National Surgical Quality Improvement Program Pediatric database was queried to identify all cleft and craniofacial surgery cases performed by plastic surgeons from 2012 to 2019 based on CPT code. Microsurgical cases and CPT codes with a case count of fewer than 10 were excluded. Efficiency was defined as total RVUs divided by total operative time (ie, RVUs/hour). Mean efficiency per CPT code was ranked and compared by quartile using t tests. RESULTS: The sample consisted of 69 CPT codes with 50,450 cases. In the top quartile, most CPT codes were craniofacial procedures including frontofacial procedures (23.53%) and craniectomies for craniosynostosis or bony lesions (35.29%) (mean, 15.65 ± 4.22 RVUs/hour). The lowest quartile was composed mainly of CPT codes for cleft procedures including operations for velopharyngeal insufficiency (17.65%), cleft palate repair (23.53%), and cleft septoplasty (5.88%) (mean, 7.39 ± 0.98 RVUs/hour; P < 0.001). It was 2.5 times more efficient for a cleft and craniofacial surgeon to perform a local skin flap (15.18 RVUs/hour) than a secondary palatal lengthening for cleft palate (6.09 RVUs/hour). CONCLUSIONS: The current RVU allocation to cleft and craniofacial procedures creates arbitrary disparities in physician efficiency, with cleft procedures disproportionately negatively affected. RVU assignments should be reevaluated to avoid disincentivizing cleft surgical care.
引用
- Rochlin DH, Chaya BF, Flores RL, et al. National Undervaluation of Cleft Surgical Services: Evidence from a Comparative Analysis of 50,450 Cases. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2022. PMID: 36730532. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000009922
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。