烧伤幸存者恐惧-回避问卷的验证及其与疼痛强度、灾难化思维和残疾的关联
本研究采用前瞻性混合方法,在烧伤幸存者中检验烧伤幸存者恐惧-回避问卷(BSFAQ)的结构效度,并分析恐惧-回避与疼痛强度、灾难化思维及残疾的关系。定性访谈组(n=31)中,恐惧-回避者与非恐惧-回避者的BSFAQ评分差异有统计学意义(P=.015),ROC曲线显示BSFAQ正确预测恐惧-回避的准确率为82.4%。二次分析(n=51)显示恐惧-回避与基线疼痛(r=.466,P=.002)、各时间点灾难化思维及伤后6个月残疾(r=-.643,P=.000)相关。
要点
- BSFAQ在烧伤幸存者中显示结构效度,能区分有无恐惧-回避信念者(P=.015)。
- BSFAQ正确预测恐惧-回避的准确率为82.4%。
- 恐惧-回避与基线疼痛、灾难化思维及伤后6个月残疾相关。
核心结论
- BSFAQ具有结构效度,能够正确预测存在恐惧-回避的烧伤幸存者,但还需进一步研究其临床测量学特性。
- 结果与恐惧-回避模型一致:表达恐惧-回避的烧伤幸存者更可能在康复早期报告更高疼痛水平,并与持续升高的灾难化思维相关,最终导致更高的自我报告残疾。
研究设计与样本
- 采用前瞻性混合方法研究,通过比较BSFAQ定量评分与独立进行的定性访谈来检验结构效度,定性访谈样本n=31。
- 二次目标数据来自回顾性病历审查,烧伤幸存者n=51,收集疼痛强度(数字评定量表)、灾难化思维(疼痛灾难化量表)和残疾(烧伤特定健康量表简版)评分。
主要发现
- 定性访谈组中,恐惧-回避者与非恐惧-回避者的BSFAQ评分差异有统计学意义(P=.015),ROC曲线显示BSFAQ正确预测恐惧-回避的准确率为82.4%。
- 恐惧-回避与基线疼痛呈中度相关(r=.466,P=.002)。
- 恐惧-回避与灾难化思维随时间呈中度相关(各时间点分别为r=.557,P=.000;r=.470,P=.00;r=.559,P=.002)。
- 恐惧-回避与伤后6个月残疾呈中度相关(r=-.643,P=.000)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
According to the Fear-avoidance (FA) model, FA beliefs can lead to disability due to avoidance of activities expected to result in pain or further injury. Extensive research on the relationship of FA, pain, catastrophizing, and disability has been generated with patients suffering from chronic neck and back pain, but little research has been conducted with burn survivors. To address this need, the Burn Survivor FA Questionnaire (BSFAQ) was developed (Langlois J, Vincent-Toskin, S, Duchesne, P et al. Fear-avoidance beliefs and behaviors of burn survivors: A mixed-methods approach. Burns 2021;47:175-89.) but has not been validated. Thus, the primary objective of this study was to investigate the construct validity of the BSFAQ among burn survivors. The secondary objective was to examine the relationship between FA and 1) pain intensity and 2) catastrophizing at baseline, 3 months and 6 months postburn, and 3) disability among burn survivors at 6 months postburn. A prospective mixed-methods approach was used to examine the construct validity by comparing the quantitative scores of the BSFAQ to independently performed qualitative interviews of burn survivors (n = 31) that explored their lived experiences, to determine if the BSFAQ discriminated those who had, from those who did not have FA beliefs. Data for the secondary objective, scores of burn survivors (n = 51) pain intensity (numeric rating scale), catastrophizing (pain catastrophizing scale), and disability (Burn Specific Health Scale-brief), were collected through a retrospective chart review. For the primary objective, Wilcoxon rank sum test results showed a statistically significant difference (P = .015) between the BSFAQ scores of participants who were identified from the qualitative interviews as fear avoidant compared to those who were identified as non fear avoidant, with a receiver operating characteristic curve indicating that the BSFAQ correctly predicted FA 82.4% of the time. For the secondary objective, Spearman correlation test results showed a moderate correlation between FA and 1) pain at baseline (r = .466, P = .002), 2) catastrophizing thoughts over time (r = .557, P = .000; r = .470, P = .00; r = .559, P = .002 respectively at each time point), and 3) disability at 6 months postburn (r = -.643, P = .000). These results support that the BSFAQ is able to discriminate which burn survivors are experiencing FA beliefs. It is also consistent with the FA model since burn survivors who express FA are more likely to report higher levels of pain early during their recovery that correlates with persistently elevated catastrophizing thoughts and ultimately results in higher self-reported disability. The BSFAQ demonstrates construct validity and is able to correctly predict fear-avoidant burn survivors; however, additional research is required to further examine the BSFAQ's clinimetric properties.
引用
- Chen J, Caluori C, Alberton L, et al. Validation of the Burn Survivor Fear-Avoidance Questionnaire and Its Association With Pain Intensity, Catastrophizing, and Disability. J Burn Care Res. 2023. PMID: 36812056. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irad025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。