非洲烧伤管理现状:挑战与解决方案
该在线调查覆盖40个非洲国家237个城市的271份问卷,评估烧伤中心的人力、基础设施与设备及感知挑战。多数应答来自极低人类发展指数国家的三级医疗机构,仅18.8%患者免费治疗,34.7%中心有独立烧伤病房。随机森林分析显示人类发展指数与死亡率显著相关,感知晚期就诊是预后差的最重要原因,建立重症监护病房和预防教育被视为最大改进潜力。
要点
- 271份问卷来自40个非洲国家237个城市,81.9%来自人类发展指数极低国家。
- 仅34.7%中心有独立烧伤病房,39.1%中心定期行皮肤移植。
- 随机森林分析显示人类发展指数与死亡率显著相关(特征重要性0.38)。
核心结论
- 低人类发展指数、延迟就诊(如先由非医师诊治)及缺乏设备等多种因素似乎会恶化烧伤结局。
- 引入重症监护病房和社区教育被认为是改善烧伤医疗保健的重要步骤。
研究设计与样本
- 在线调查覆盖烧伤中心的人力资源、基础设施和医疗设备以及感知挑战与改进要点。
- 调查以英文和法文通过滚雪球法分发。
- 共分析来自40个非洲国家237个城市的271份问卷。
- 应用描述性统计和基于人工智能的随机森林分析识别报告死亡率降低的决定因素。
主要发现
- 271份问卷中222份(81.9%)来自人类发展指数极低(第四四分位)国家。
- 多数应答(154份,56.8%)来自三级卫生保健机构。
- 仅18.8%(n=51)的患者治疗免费。
- 多数中心有1至3名专科医生(n=131,48.3%)、1至3名全科医生(n=138,50.9%)和超过4名护士(n=175,64.6%)。
- 94个中心(34.7%)有独立烧伤病房,165个中心(39.1%)定期行皮肤移植。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Understand the availability of human resources, infrastructure and medical equipment and perceived improvement helps to address interventions to improve burn care. METHODS: Online survey covering human resources, infrastructure, and medical equipment of burn centers as well as perceived challenges and points for improvement. The survey was distributed in English and French via snowball method. Descriptive statistics and AI-based technique random forest analysis was applied to identify determinants for a reduction of the reported mortality rate. RESULTS: 271 questionnaires from 237 cities in 40 African countries were analyzed. 222 (81.9 %) from countries with a very low Human Development Index (HDI) (4th quartile). The majority (154, 56.8 %) of all responses were from tertiary health care facilities. In only 18.8 % (n = 51) therapy was free of charge for the patients. The majority (n = 131, 48.3 %) had between 1 and 3 specialist doctors (n = 131, 48.3 %), 1 to 3 general doctors (n = 138, 50.9 %) and more than 4 nurses (n = 175, 64.6 %). A separate burn ward was available in 94 (34.7 %) centers. Regular skin grafting was performed in 165 (39.1 %) centers. Random forest-based analysis revealed a significant association between HDI (feature importance: 0.38) and mortality. The most important reason for poor outcome was perceived late presentation (212 institutions, 78.2 %). The greatest perceived potential for improvement was introduction of intensive care units (229 institutions, 84.5 %), and prevention or education (227 institutions, 83.7 %). INTERPRETATION: A variety of factors, including a low HDI, delayed hospital presentation e.g. due to prior care by non-physicians and lack of equipment seem to worsen the outcome. Introduction of an intensive care unit and communal education are perceived to be important steps in improving health care in burns.
引用
- Lindert J, Bbaale D, Mohr C, et al. State of burns management in Africa: Challenges and solutions. Burns. 2023. PMID: 36759220. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2022.12.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。