整形与重建外科中的众包研究:系统综述与报告建议
该系统综述由持证图书馆员与整形外科主治医师制定检索策略,经两名独立评审者筛选后纳入45项研究,评估整形与重建外科众包研究的主题、参与者及效应量,发现颅颌面与美容手术合计占半数以上,并总结出参与者特征、费用、周期和调查条目数等报告现状。
要点
- 颅颌面与美容手术合计占纳入众包研究的半数以上。
- 众包参与者多来自美国、女性、异性恋、25至35岁、大学学历、年收入2万至5万美元。
- 研究通常评估审美感知,费用约350美元,中位运行9天,约含60个独特调查条目和约40张独特人物图像。
核心结论
- 众包是一种相对新颖、低成本的方法,可从普通人群获取大量数据,可能增进对整形与重建外科公众认知的理解。
- 与其他新兴领域一样,众包研究在受试者数量、受试者补偿和方法学方面存在显著变异性,提示有质量改进的机会。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述:由持证图书馆员与整形外科主治医师制定系统检索策略,检索整形与重建外科中所有使用众包的文章。
- 使用Covidence系统综述管理软件,由两名独立评审者导入文章、筛选摘要、评估全文并提取数据。
- 2021年10月8日执行的检索共获得168项研究,最终纳入45项。
主要发现
- 颅颌面外科与美容外科合计占纳入研究的半数以上。
- 整形外科众包研究的参与者更常见来自美国、女性、异性恋、25至35岁、已完成大学教育、年收入2万至5万美元。
- 研究通常评估审美感知,费用约350美元,中位运行9天,约包含60个独特调查条目和约40张独特人物图像。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Crowdsourcing uses online platforms to collect large data from laypersons and has been increasingly used over the past 5 years to answer questions about aesthetic and functional outcomes following plastic and reconstructive surgery. This systematic review evaluates crowdsourcing articles in plastic and reconstructive surgery based on study topic, participants, and effect size in the hopes of describing best practices. METHODS: A systematic search strategy was developed with a licensed librarian and attending plastic surgeon to query all articles using crowdsourcing in plastic and reconstructive surgery. Covidence systematic review manager was used by two independent reviewers to import articles, screen abstracts, evaluate full texts, and extract data. RESULTS: A search run on October 8, 2021, yielded 168 studies, of which 45 were ultimately included. Craniofacial surgery and aesthetic surgery collectively constituted over half of studies. Participants in plastic surgery crowdsourcing studies are more commonly from the United States, female, straight, 25 to 35 years old; have completed college; and earn $20,000 to $50,000 per year. Studies typically assessed aesthetic perceptions, cost approximately $350, ran a median of 9 days, included approximately 60 unique survey items, and included approximately 40 unique human images. CONCLUSIONS: Crowdsourcing is a relatively new, low-cost method of garnering high-volume data from laypersons that may further our understanding of public perception in plastic and reconstructive surgery. As with other nascent fields, there is significant variability in number of subjects used, subject compensation, and methodology, indicating an opportunity for quality improvement.
引用
- Villavisanis DF, Blum JD, Cheung L, et al. Crowdsourcing in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery: A Systematic Review with Reporting Recommendations. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2023. PMID: 36727828. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000010232
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。