文献速递美容整形

三种眉提升术式一年 sustainability 的前瞻性评估

One-year sustainability of brow-lifting procedures.
PubMed 文献 · J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg · 2022-12-19

本研究对36例同时行上睑成形术并接受三种眉提升术式之一(直接眉固定术8例、经睑眉提升术10例、EndotineⓇ额部固定术18例)的患者,于术前和术后12个月测量三个垂直距离并调查满意度。结果显示各组术后一年均出现轻度眉下降,客观结果不支持眉位置提升的假设,但患者和术者主观满意度仍提示美学改善。

要点

  • 直接眉固定术8例,术后一年瞳孔水平下降1.2 mm、外眦水平下降2.1 mm、眶缘水平下降0.6 mm。
  • 经睑眉提升术10例,术后一年瞳孔水平下降0.7 mm、外眦水平下降0.3 mm,眶缘水平轻微上升0.7 mm但无统计学意义。
  • EndotineⓇ额部固定术18例,术后一年瞳孔水平下降1.1 mm、外眦水平下降1.2 mm、眶缘水平下降0.7 mm。

核心结论

  • 患者术后12个月出现轻度眉下降,因此眉提升术式的可持续性受到质疑,需要重新评估。
  • 术者主观意见和患者总体满意度提示美学改善,尽管客观结果否定了术后一年眉位置提升的假设。
  • 原文讨论的可能原因包括剥离范围、上睑成形术切除的下拉作用以及额肌活动减少。

研究设计与样本

  • 本研究为前瞻性研究,在本院对36例患者行上睑成形术并同时实施三种眉提升术式之一。
  • 三种术式分别为直接(切除)眉固定术、经睑眉提升术和EndotineⓇ额部固定术。
  • 于术前和术后12个月对瞳孔、外眦和眶缘水平三个固定解剖点进行三个垂直距离的模拟和数字测量。
  • 通过纸质问卷调查患者和术者对功能和美学结果的满意度。

主要发现

  • 直接眉固定术8例,术后一年瞳孔水平下降1.2 mm、外眦水平下降2.1 mm、眶缘水平下降0.6 mm。
  • 经睑眉提升术10例,术后一年瞳孔水平下降0.7 mm、外眦水平下降0.3 mm,眶缘水平轻微上升0.7 mm但无统计学意义。
  • EndotineⓇ额部固定术18例,术后一年瞳孔水平下降1.1 mm、外眦水平下降1.2 mm、眶缘水平下降0.7 mm。
  • 术者主观意见和患者总体满意度提示美学改善。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Unlike blepharoplasty or facelifting procedures, there is little evidence of the sustainability of brow-lifting techniques. OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to investigate the one-year sustainability of three brow-lifting techniques performed at our department. METHODS: Thirty-six patients received an upper blepharoplasty and simultaneously one of three brow-lifting procedures: the direct (excisional) browpexy, the transpalpebral brow lift, and the EndotineⓇ forehead fixation. analogue and digital measurements of 3 vertical distances, from fixed anatomical points at pupil, lateral canthal, and lateral orbital rim level, were performed preoperatively and 12 months postoperatively. Patients' and surgeons' satisfaction considering functional and aesthetic outcomes were investigated by carrying out paper-pencil surveys. RESULTS: Direct browpexy was performed in 8, transpalpebral eyebrow lift in 10, and the EndotineⓇ fixation in 18 of the cases. In the first year, direct browpexy showed a general descent of 1.2 mm at the pupil level, 2.1 mm at the lateral canthal, and 0.6 mm at the orbital rim level. In the transpalpebral eyebrow lift group, a descent of 0.7 mm at the pupil level and 0.3 mm at the lateral canthal level was found; the orbital rim level showed a slight but nonsignificant ascent of 0.7 mm. In the EndotineⓇ group, a descent of 1.1 mm at the pupil level, 1.2 mm at the lateral canthal level, and 0.7 mm at the orbital rim level was shown. Subjective surgeon opinions and overall patient satisfaction underline an aesthetic improvement despite objective results falsifying the hypothesis of a raised eyebrow position after one year. CONCLUSION: Patients showed minor eyebrow decrement after 12 months postoperatively; therefore, sustainability is questioned and must be reevaluated. The extent of dissection, the downward pull of upper blepharoplasty resection, and the decrease in frontalis muscle activity are discussed as the possible causes.

来源:J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Beck H, Egger K, Koller R, et al. One-year sustainability of brow-lifting procedures. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2022. PMID: 36669433. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2022.12.008

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。