幼儿手掌烧伤后预测瘢痕的皮肤功能单元的可靠性、效度与预测效度
本研究评估手掌烧伤后预测瘢痕的29个皮肤功能单元(CFU)的评估者间信度与效度。39例儿童(40只手)接受三名烧伤治疗师面对面评估,照片评估至少6个月后进行,伤后3至6个月再评估确定瘢痕。面对面评估八个CFU组信度极好(ICC2,1 0.83-0.96),照片评估六组信度好至极好(ICC2,1 0.69-0.90),七组效度(ICC2,1 0.66-0.87),七组预测效度好至极好(面对面ICC2,1 0.60-0.95,照片ICC2,1 0.69-0.89)。
要点
- 面对面评估八个CFU组评估者间信度极好(ICC2,1 0.83-0.96)。
- 照片评估六个CFU组信度好至极好(ICC2,1 0.69-0.90)。
- 两种评估方式对七个CFU组预测效度好至极好。
核心结论
- 有经验的治疗师可通过面对面或照片可靠评估CFU并预测未来瘢痕发展。
研究设计与样本
- 39例儿童(40只手)手掌烧伤愈合后由三名烧伤治疗师面对面评估,初始照片至少6个月后由同一治疗师评估,伤后3至6个月再面对面评估确定瘢痕,29个CFU合并为八个组分析。
主要发现
- 面对面评估八个CFU组评估者间信度极好(ICC2,1 0.83-0.96)。
- 照片评估六个CFU组信度好至极好(ICC2,1 0.69-0.90),七个CFU组效度ICC2,1 0.66-0.87。
- 两种评估方式对七个CFU组预测瘢痕效度好至极好(面对面ICC2,1 0.60-0.95,照片ICC2,1 0.69-0.89)。
关键数值与推荐
- 面对面评估八个CFU组ICC2,1 0.83-0.96。
- 照片评估六个CFU组ICC2,1 0.69-0.90,七个CFU组效度ICC2,1 0.66-0.87。
- 预测效度七个CFU组:面对面ICC2,1 0.60-0.95,照片ICC2,1 0.69-0.89。
临床怎么用
- 有经验的治疗师可通过面对面或照片评估CFU并预测未来瘢痕发展。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Identification of children at risk of palmar burn scar is important for early initiation of scar management. This study determined the interrater reliability of face-to-face and photographic assessments of 29 palmar cutaneous functional units (CFUs) predicted to scar following palmar burn. The validity of photographic compared to face-to-face assessment, and the predictive validity of both assessment types to identify scarring at 3 to 6 months following burn, was also established. Thirty-nine children (40 hands) post burn injury were assessed face-to-face in the clinical setting, following healing of their palmar burn, by three burn therapists. Photographs of the children's hands at initial assessment were assessed by the same therapists a minimum of 6 months later. To determine which CFUs scarred, children were reassessed face-to-face in the clinical setting 3 to 6 months following their burn. For analysis, 29 CFUs were merged into eight separate groups to determine the number of CFUs predicted to scar per CFU group for face-to-face and photographic assessments. The range of agreement for individual CFUs within CFU groups was also calculated for both assessment types. Excellent interrater reliability was established for face-to-face assessment in all eight CFU groups (ICC2,1 0.83-0.96). Photographic assessment demonstrated good to excellent interrater reliability in six CFU groups (ICC2,1 0.69-0.90) and validity in seven CFU groups (ICC2,1 0.66-0.87). Good to excellent predictive validity was established for both assessment types in seven CFU groups (face-to-face ICC2,1 0.60-0.95, photographic ICC2,1 0.69-0.89). Experienced therapists can reliably assess CFUs face-to-face or via photographs and predict future scar development.
引用
- Thomas R, Wicks S, Toose C, et al. Reliability, Validity, and Predictive Validity of Cutaneous Functional Units Predicted to Scar Following Palmar Burn Injury in Young Children. J Burn Care Res. 2023. PMID: 36478206. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irac179
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。