开发单侧唇腭裂术前婴儿正畸人体测量评估核心结局集:e-Delphi共识
本研究通过文献检索识别单侧唇腭裂(UCLP)术前婴儿正畸(PSIO)的人体测量指标,并采用e-Delphi共识法,由10名专家经三轮评议,以效度V系数≥80%为标准,最终确定包含18项人体测量指标的核心结局集。该核心结局集被共识专家验证为临床有用且低成本工具,用于PSIO有效性研究。
要点
- 文献共识别101项用于评估UCLP中PSIO的人体测量指标。
- 经10名专家三轮e-Delphi共识,以效度V系数≥80%为标准,确定18项核心指标。
- 核心集包括鼻小柱高度、鼻尖突出度、鼻翼突出长度、鼻孔宽度等指标。
核心结论
- 标准化结局测量对于评估和确保唇腭裂治疗质量是必要的。
- 经共识专家验证的人体测量评估核心结局集是用于PSIO有效性研究的临床有用且低成本工具。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为e-Delphi共识研究,通过文献检索识别人体测量指标,并由10名主题专家进行三轮评议。
主要发现
- 文献共识别101项用于评估UCLP中PSIO的人体测量指标。
- 共识验证了核心结局集的内容,共包含18项人体测量指标。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识标准为效度V系数≥80%,指标被认为必要以评估UCLP中的PSIO。
- 核心结局集包含18项指标:鼻小柱高度、鼻尖突出度、鼻翼突出长度、鼻孔宽度、鼻基底宽度、鼻小柱角度、唇裂段、非裂侧唇高、裂侧唇高、段间距离、牙弓长度、大段长度、小段长度、切牙点侧向偏斜、腭裂后部宽度、牙弓宽度、大段旋转和小段旋转。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Presurgical infant orthopaedics (PSIO) in infants with cleft lip and palate focuses on improving the anatomical conditions of the lip, palate and nose before the first lip surgery; however, its effectiveness has not been proven. OBJECTIVE: To develop a core outcome set for reporting anthropometry-based outcomes in studies appraising the PSIO before primary cleft lip repair in unilateral cleft lip palate (UCLP). METHOD: Literature search to identify anthropometric measures. The operational definition and schematic representation of each were elaborated, grouping those apparently the same. By using Delphi methodology with a consensus of 10 subject-matter experts, three rounds were conducted to select a core outcome set of anthropometric measures with a validity V coefficient ≥80% among considered necessary to evaluate the PSIO in UCLP. RESULTS: A total of 101 anthropometric measures were identified in the literature to evaluate PSIO in UCLP. Of these, consensus validated the content of the core outcome set, which comprises 18 anthropometric measures, including columella height, nasal tip projection, projection alar length, width of nostril, nasal basal width, angle of columella, cleft lip segment, height of the non-cleft lip, height of the cleft lip, intersegment distance, arch length, greater segment length, lesser segment length, lateral deviation of the incisal point, posterior width of palatal cleft, arch width, grater segment rotation and lesser segment rotation. CONCLUSIONS: Standardised outcome measures are necessary to evaluate and ensure the quality of treatment in CLP. The core outcome set for anthropometric evaluation validated by consensus subject-matter experts is a clinically useful and low-cost tool for PSIO effectiveness studies.
引用
- Castillo T, Luisa PPM, Clark P, et al. Developing a core outcome set for anthropometric evaluation for presurgical infant orthopaedics for unilateral cleft lip and palate: e-Delphi consensus. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2022. PMID: 36075806. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2022.06.065
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。