微工具:显微外科验证性评估工具的系统综述
本系统综述通过Covidence筛选文献,分析显微外科验证性评估工具,评估其效度、偏倚、复杂度和保真度及信度。共纳入13种工具,分为整体评估和终产物评估两类;所有工具均达到结构效度,11种工具显示评分者间信度,GRS和UWOMSA达到评分者内信度。
要点
- 13种显微外科评估工具经验证,均达到结构效度
- 11种工具显示评分者间信度,GRS和UWOMSA达评分者内信度
- 终产物内膜评估工具和帝国学院外科评估装置是客观评估显微外科技能的有效工具
核心结论
- 13种评估工具在显微外科应用中达到不同程度的效度,其中11种显示评分者间信度,GRS和UWOMSA达到评分者内信度。
- 终产物内膜评估工具和帝国学院外科评估装置是客观评估显微外科技能的有效工具。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,使用Covidence筛选文献,关键词包括「显微外科」「模拟」「终产物评估」和「能力」。
- 纳入标准为同时展示技能获取训练和评估的模拟模型,排除独立于技术评估的训练工具及不含微血管吻合的工具。
- 使用PRISMA和SWiM指南对每种评估工具评估效度、偏倚、复杂度和保真度及信度。
主要发现
- 13种不同的工具经验证可用于显微外科评估,分为整体评估和终产物评估两类。
- 10种工具评估手术「过程」,3种工具为专门的终产物评估。
- 所有工具均达到结构效度。
- 仅UWOMSA和GRS评估了校标效度。
- 除ISSLA和SAMS外,每种工具均显示评分者间信度;4种工具显示了预测效度。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Microsurgery is a technically demanding aspect of surgery that is integral to a variety of sub-specialties. Microsurgery is required in high-risk cases where time is limited and pressure is high, so there is increasing demand for skills acquisition beforehand. The aim of this review was to analyse the available literature on validated microsurgical assessment tools. METHODS: Covidence was used to screen papers for inclusion. Keywords included 'microsurgery', 'simulation', 'end-product assessment' and 'competence'. Inclusion criteria specified simulation models which demonstrate training and assessment of skill acquisition simultaneously. Tools which were used for training independently of technical assessment were excluded and so were tools which did not include a microvascular anastomosis. Each assessment tool was evaluated for validity, bias, complexity and fidelity and reliability using PRISMA and SWiM guidelines. RESULTS: Thirteen distinct tools were validated for use in microsurgical assessment. These can be divided into overall assessment and end-product assessment. Ten tools assessed the 'journey' of the operation, and three tools were specifically end-product assessments. All tools achieved construct validity. Criterion validity was only assessed for the UWOMSA1 and GRS.2 Interrater reliability was demonstrated for each tool except the ISSLA3 and SAMS.4 Four of the tools addressed demonstrate predictive validity.4-7 CONCLUSION: Thirteen assessment tools achieve variable validity for use in microsurgery. Interrater reliability is demonstrated for 11 of the 13 tools. The GRS and UWOMSA achieve intrarater reliability. The End Product Intimal Assessment tool and the Imperial College of Surgical Assessment device were valid tools for objective assessment of microsurgical skill.
引用
- Milling R, Carolan D, Pafitanis G, et al. Microtools: A systematic review of validated assessment tools in microsurgery. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2022. PMID: 36151038. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2022.06.092
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。