整形外科期刊系统综述方法学质量的系统评价
该研究对2019年7月至2020年7月间三本知名整形外科期刊发表的系统综述(SR)进行批判性评价,采用AMSTAR工具评估方法学质量。共纳入76篇研究,中位AMSTAR评分为3.5分(范围0-7),含Meta分析(MA)的SR评分显著高于仅SR(中位5分 vs 3分,p<0.001)。多数SR认为现有原始研究不足,结论价值有限。
要点
- 含Meta分析的系统综述AMSTAR评分中位5分,显著高于仅系统综述的3分(p<0.001)。
- 中国来源论文AMSTAR评分显著高于美国,颅颌面亚专业评分显著高于其他亚专业。
- 多数系统综述认为现有原始研究不足,推荐开展更多研究。
核心结论
- 整形外科系统综述的方法学质量总体较低,其结论价值有限。
- 外科医生应熟悉系统综述和Meta分析方法学,以便更好地判断并将研究结果应用于临床实践。
研究设计与样本
- 对2019年7月至2020年7月间发表于三本知名整形外科期刊的系统综述进行批判性评价。
- 研究筛选与评价由两人重复独立完成,采用AMSTAR工具评估。
- 共纳入76篇研究,其中52篇(68%)仅为系统综述,24篇(32%)包含Meta分析。
主要发现
- 最常见的亚专业领域包括乳腺、颅颌面和手外科。
- 78%的研究遵循PRISMA指南。
- AMSTAR评分中位数(最小值,最大值)为3.5(0-7)。
- 含Meta分析的系统综述AMSTAR评分显著高于仅系统综述(p<0.001),中位评分分别为5分和3分。
- 来自中国的论文AMSTAR评分显著高于美国;颅颌面系统综述评分显著高于所有其他亚专业领域。
临床怎么用
- 外科医生应熟悉系统综述和Meta分析方法学,以便更好地判断并将研究结果应用于临床实践。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Systematic reviews (SR) and meta-analyses (MA) are described as the top level of evidence in clinical research and are commonplace in plastic surgery literature. Their quality is limited both by the reliability of primary studies and the method of aggregating data. This study analysed the overall quality of SR's in plastic surgery and identified influencing factors. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The paper critically appraised SR's published in three prominent plastic surgery journals between July 2019 and July 2020. Study selection and appraisal was performed in duplicate. Articles were assessed using A Measurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews (AMSTAR). RESULTS: Seventy-six studies were included. 52 (68%) were SR's only and 24 (32%) included meta-analysis (MA) as well. The most common subspecialty areas included breast, craniofacial and hand. 78% of studies followed the PRISMA guidelines. The median (min, max) AMSTAR score was 3.5 (0-7). SR's with MA had significantly higher AMSTAR scores (p<0.001) than SR's alone, with median scores of 5 and 3 respectively. Papers from China had significantly higher AMSTAR scores than the USA. Craniofacial SR's had significantly higher scores than all other subspecialty areas. Most SR's reviewed concluded that there is currently inadequate primary research to make a conclusion and recommended more research be carried out in that area. CONCLUSIONS: This systematicreview found overall that the quality of research methodology in Plastic Surgery SRs is low, and their conclusions of limited value. Surgeons should be familiar with SR and MA methodology, so they can exercise better judgement in applying findings to clinical practice.
引用
- Savage N, Savage S, Doherty Z, et al. A systematic review of systematic review methodology in plastic surgery journals. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2022. PMID: 35970743. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2022.08.004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。