二氧化碳激光与脉冲染料激光联合及单独治疗烧伤增生性瘢痕的效用分析
本研究将25例烧伤增生性瘢痕患者的3个3×3 cm方形区域随机分配至CO2激光、脉冲染料激光(PDL)或CO2+PDL联合治疗,共3次治疗、间隔4至6周,随访3至6个月。CO2或PDL单独治疗均使患者与观察者瘢痕评估量表评分从第1次至第3次访视显著下降(P=0.01和0.01)。结论认为激光可改善烧伤增生性瘢痕,但联合治疗较单独治疗无临床有意义的额外获益。
要点
- CO2或PDL单独治疗均使POSAS评分从第1次至第3次访视显著下降(P=0.01和0.01)。
- 厚瘢痕(≥0.3 cm)在第1至2次访视间所有激光方式均显著变薄。
- 联合治疗较单独治疗无临床有意义的额外获益。
核心结论
- 不同年龄、病因和厚度的烧伤增生性瘢痕中,较厚瘢痕在CO2、PDL或联合治疗的早期均见更大幅度变薄;但联合治疗较单独治疗无临床有意义的获益。
- 这些数据支持使用激光改善烧伤增生性瘢痕,但不支持某一方式或联合方式优于另一方式。
研究设计与样本
- 患者接受烧伤增生性瘢痕激光治疗并入组,将3个3×3 cm方形瘢痕区域随机分配至CO2激光、PDL或CO2+PDL治疗。
- 患者接受3次治疗、间隔4至6周,随访3至6个月;每次访视治疗前进行瘢痕评估,包括照片、超声、色度计和患者与观察者瘢痕评估量表。
- 共25例患者入组,20例完成2次治疗(80%),11例完成全部3次治疗(44%)。
主要发现
- 初始瘢痕厚度中位数为0.3 cm,伤后时间中位数为8个月。
- CO2或PDL治疗的烧伤增生性瘢痕,患者与观察者瘢痕评估量表评分从第1次至第3次访视显著下降(分别为P=0.01和P=0.01)。
- 按厚度分层,厚瘢痕(≥0.3 cm)在第1至2次访视间所有激光方式均显著变薄(CO2+PDL,P=0.01;CO2,P=0.02;PDL,P=0.03)。
- 薄瘢痕(<0.3 cm)在第3次访视时CO2+PDL或PDL单独治疗均见厚度减少(分别为P=0.01和P=0.04)。
- 按瘢痕年龄分层,年轻瘢痕(<9个月)CO2治疗在第1至2次访视间显著变薄(P=0.04),CO2+PDL治疗在第2至3次访视间显著变薄(P=0.04);PDL治疗至第3次访视才见显著变薄(P=0.002)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为这些数据支持使用激光改善烧伤增生性瘢痕,但不支持某一方式或联合方式优于另一方式。
局限性
- 25例入组患者中仅20例完成2次治疗(80%),11例完成全部3次治疗(44%)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Hypertrophic burn scars (HTBSs) remain a significant source of morbidity. Contemporary treatment has evolved to use CO2 lasers and/or pulse-dye lasers (PDLs) to reduce scar thickness (ST) and erythema. This study seeks to compare treatment efficacy with CO2 or PDL individually and in combination. METHODS: Patients undergoing laser treatments for HTBSs were enrolled. Three 3 × 3 cm squares of HTBSs were randomized to receive treatment with CO2 laser, PDL or CO2 + PDL. Patients underwent 3 treatments, 4 to 6 weeks apart and were followed up over 3 to 6 months. Scar assessments occurred at each visit before treatment and consisted of photographs, ultrasound, colorimetry, and the Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Score. RESULTS: Twenty-five patients were enrolled. Twenty completed 2 treatments (80%) and 11 completed all 3 treatments (44%). Median initial ST was 0.3 cm. Median time since injury was 8 months. Hypertrophic burn scars treated with CO2 or PDL showed a significant decrease in Patient and Observer Scar Assessment Scale score from visit 1 to 3 (P = 0.01 and 0.01, respectively). When separated by ST, thick scars (≥0.3 cm) showed a significant decrease in thickness between visit 1 and 2 using all laser modalities (CO2 + PDL, P = 0.01; CO2, P = 0.02; PDL, P = 0.03). Thin scars (<0.3 cm) showed a reduction in thickness by visit 3 after CO2 + PDL or PDL alone (P = 0.01 and 0.04, respectively). Separating scars by age, younger scars (<9 months) showed a significant reduction in thickness between visit 1 and 2 for CO2 treatment (P = 0.04), and between visit 2 and 3 for CO2 + PDL treatment (P = 0.04). Hypertrophic burn scars treated with PDL did not demonstrate a significant reduction in thickness until visit 3 (P = 0.002). Older scars (≥9 months) showed a significant reduction in thickness between visit 1 and 2 only after CO2 + PDL (P = 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Hypertrophic burn scars of varying ages, etiologies, and thicknesses were examined in this study with greater degree of early reduction seen in thicker scars using all laser modalities of CO2, PDL or in combination. However, there was no clinically meaningful benefit found with combination as compared with individual treatment. These data support the use of laser to improve HTBS but does not support one modality or combination of modalities over another.
引用
- Cooper LE, Nuutila K, Kemp Bohan PM, et al. Analysis of the Utility of CO2 and Pulse-Dye Lasers Together and Separately in the Treatment of Hypertrophic Burn Scars. Ann Plast Surg. 2022. PMID: 35943226. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000003240
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。