烧伤复苏综述:Plasmalyte®能否作为林格乳酸盐的等效替代选择?
林格乳酸盐数十年来是烧伤复苏最广泛使用的液体,而新型平衡晶体液Plasmalyte®(PL)在危重症包括烧伤患者中日益流行。本叙述性综述检索指导烧伤液体管理的证据,并探讨支持平衡晶体液尤其PL用于烧伤复苏的数据;文献检索仅发现一项直接比较PL与标准林格乳酸盐用于烧伤复苏的研究,基于有限文献难以得出有意义的结论,在广泛更改处方集之前需要进一步研究PL用于烧伤的适宜性。
要点
- 林格乳酸盐数十年来是烧伤复苏最广泛使用的液体。
- PL理论上提供有利的代谢特征且成本相对较低,在危重症中日益流行。
- 检索仅发现一项直接比较PL与林格乳酸盐用于烧伤复苏的研究。
核心结论
- 基于PL用于烧伤的有限文献,难以得出有意义的结论,在广泛更改处方集之前需要进一步研究PL用于烧伤的适宜性。
研究设计与样本
- 叙述性综述,检索指导烧伤液体管理的证据及支持平衡晶体液尤其PL用于烧伤复苏的数据;文献检索仅发现一项直接比较PL与标准林格乳酸盐用于烧伤复苏的研究。
主要发现
- 林格乳酸盐数十年来是烧伤复苏最广泛使用的液体。
- PL作为一种较新的平衡晶体液,在危重症包括烧伤患者中日益流行,部分因其理论上提供有利的代谢特征,也可能归因于其相对较低的成本。
- 大面积烧伤危重症患者在复苏期接受巨大容量液体,所选平衡晶体液类型可能影响患者代谢状态和总体结局。
- 文献检索仅发现一项研究直接比较PL与标准林格乳酸盐用于烧伤复苏。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 文献检索仅发现一项直接比较PL与标准林格乳酸盐用于烧伤复苏的研究,基于PL用于烧伤的有限文献难以得出有意义的结论。
- 在广泛更改处方集之前需要进一步研究PL用于烧伤的适宜性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Ringer's lactate has been the most widely used fluid for burn resuscitation for decades. Plasmalyte® (PL), a newer balanced crystalloid, is gaining popularity for use in the critically ill, including patients with burns. This popularity is partly due to the fact that PL theoretically offers a favorable metabolic profile, but may also be attributed to its relatively lower cost. Patients who are critically ill with large burns receive enormous volumes of fluids, especially during the resuscitation period. The choice of balanced crystalloid solution used is likely to have an impact on the metabolic status of patients and their overall outcomes. The choice of fluid for burn resuscitation has been one of the most researched topics in burn care and various types of fluids have been superseded based on research findings. This narrative review examines the evidence guiding fluid management in burns and explores the data supporting the use of balanced crystalloid solutions, in particular PL for burn resuscitation. Our literature search revealed only one study that focused on a direct comparison between PL and standard Ringer's Lactate for burn resuscitation. Based on the limited literature on the use of PL in burns, it is difficult to draw meaningful conclusions. Further research, into the suitability of PL for use in burns, is needed before formulary changes are instituted widely.
引用
- Cappuyns L, Tridente A, Stubbington Y, et al. Review of Burn Resuscitation: Is Plasmalyte® a Comparable Alternative to Ringer's Lactate? J Burn Care Res. 2023. PMID: 35917832. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irac106
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。