英国报纸中整形与美容外科医生的表述情况
该研究检索了2016年9月至2021年9月间英国读者量最大的八份报纸,共阅读2326篇文章,其中219篇提及具体命名的医生;136篇涉及「整形外科医生」,其中22名(16%)医生未在GMC整形外科专科注册;83篇涉及「美容外科医生」,其中39名(47%)在整形外科注册,11名(13%)在其他高级外科注册(耳鼻喉科2名、眼科9名),18名(22%)注册为全科医生,15名(18%)未在任何专科注册。作者认为存在将实施美容手术的个体误称为整形外科医生的现象。
要点
- 共阅读2326篇报纸文章,219篇提及具体命名的医生。
- 136篇提及「整形外科医生」,其中22名(16%)未在GMC整形外科专科注册。
- 83篇提及「美容外科医生」,其中39名(47%)在整形外科注册,15名(18%)未在任何专科注册。
核心结论
- 作者认为,无论专科或培训背景如何,实施美容手术的个体被误称为整形外科医生,这妨碍了公众对整形与重建外科作为独立专科真正范围的认识。
研究设计与样本
- 基于读者量选取英国前八份报纸,检索2016年9月至2021年9月间使用关键词「整形外科医生」或「美容外科医生」的文章,并在GMC注册名录中查询所提及医生的专科注册情况。
主要发现
- 共阅读2326篇文章,2107篇(91%)因未提及具体命名的医生而被排除,剩余219篇。
- 136篇提及「整形外科医生」,其中22名(16%)医生未在GMC整形外科专科注册。
- 83篇提及「美容外科医生」,其中39名(47%)在整形外科注册,11名(13%)在其他高级外科注册(耳鼻喉科2名、眼科9名),18名(22%)注册为全科医生,15名(18%)未在任何专科注册。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to investigate the use of the terms "plastic surgeon" or "cosmetic surgeon" in British newspapers. METHODS: Based on readership volume, the top eight British newspapers were searched for articles written between 09/2016-09/2021 for their use of keywords "plastic surgeon" OR "cosmetic surgeon". The names of the doctors referenced were searched in the GMC register to determine their speciality registration. RESULTS: A total of 2326 articles were read. 2107 (91%) articles were excluded as they did not refer to a specifically named doctor. Of the 219 articles remaining, 136 referenced "plastic surgeons". 22 (16%) doctors referred to as "plastic surgeons" were not on the GMC speciality register for plastic surgery. 83 articles made reference to "cosmetic surgeons". 39 (47%) were on the plastic surgery register but 11 (13%) were on other higher surgical registers [ENT (2) and ophthalmology (9)]. 18 (22%) cosmetic surgeons were registered as GPs and 15 (18%) were not on any speciality register. DISCUSSION: There is mis-representation of individuals performing cosmetic procedures as plastic surgeons regardless of their speciality or training. This prevents public awareness of the true scope of plastic and reconstructive surgery as a speciality in its own right.
引用
- Goodarzi MR, Breakey RWF, Jones AP, et al. Representation of plastic and cosmetic surgeons in British newspapers. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2022. PMID: 35778361. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2022.06.048
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。