转诊医院与烧伤中心对烧伤面积和烧伤深度临床评估的一致性:一项系统综述
该系统综述检索截至2021年11月6日的文献,纳入28项横断面研究共6461例患者,评估转诊单位与烧伤中心对烧伤面积百分比和烧伤深度临床评估的一致性。所有研究显示烧伤面积百分比一致性低,多数研究高估比例达50%或更高;烧伤深度研究显示55%与烧伤中心估计相同。证据确定性为烧伤面积低(GRADE ⊕⊕ОО)、烧伤深度和复苏极低(GRADE ⊕ООО)。
要点
- 转诊医院对烧伤面积百分比的高估非常频繁。
- 转诊单位与烧伤中心烧伤面积百分比评估一致性低。
- 烧伤深度临床评估的证据确定性极低(GRADE ⊕ООО)。
核心结论
- 转诊医院对烧伤面积百分比的高估非常频繁。
- 转诊中心临床评估准确性的总体证据确定性为烧伤面积低、烧伤深度极低。
- 研究结果提示烧伤界在教育和与转诊机构同事沟通方面面临重大挑战,且需要高质量研究。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,纳入标准依据PICO(患者、干预、比较、结局)定义。
- 检索相关数据库,检索日期为2021年11月6日。
- 共检索到412篇摘要,纳入28项研究共6461例患者,所有研究均报告烧伤面积百分比,其中一项报告烧伤深度。
- 所有研究均为横断面研究,大多数为回顾性纳入的连续队列。
主要发现
- 所有研究显示转诊单位与烧伤中心计算的烧伤面积百分比之间一致性低。
- 大多数直接比较转诊机构和烧伤中心烧伤面积百分比估计的研究显示,高估比例达50%或更高。
- 烧伤深度研究显示55%与烧伤中心的估计相同。
- 大多数研究存在严重研究局限性,不精确风险高。
- 转诊中心临床估计准确性的总体证据确定性:烧伤面积百分比为低(GRADE ⊕⊕ОО),烧伤深度和复苏为极低(GRADE ⊕ООО)。
关键数值与推荐
- 采用GRADE方法评估证据确定性。
- 采用QUADAS-2工具将单个研究的偏倚风险评为高、低或不清楚。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 大多数研究存在严重研究局限性,不精确风险高。
- 转诊中心临床估计准确性的总体证据确定性为烧伤面积低(GRADE ⊕⊕ОО)、烧伤深度和复苏极低(GRADE ⊕ООО)。
- 研究结果提示需要高质量研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The quality of burn care is highly dependent on the initial assessment and care. The aim of this systematic review was to investigate the agreement of clinical assessment of burn depth and %TBSA between the referring units and the receiving burn centres. METHODS: Included articles had to meet criteria defined in a PICO (patients, interventions, comparisons, outcomes). Relevant databases were searched using a predetermined search string (November 6th 2021). Data were extracted in a standardised fashion. The Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) approach for test accuracy was used to assess the certainty of evidence. The QUADAS-2 tool was used to assess the risk of bias of individual studies as 'high', 'low' or 'unclear'. RESULTS: A total of 412 abstracts were retrieved and of these 28 studies with a total of 6461 patients were included, all reporting %TBSA and one burn depth. All studies were cross-sectional and most of them comprising retrospectively enrolled consecutive cohort. All studies showed a low agreement between %TBSA calculations made at referring units and at burn centres. Most studies directly comparing estimations of %TBSA at referring institutions and burn centers showed a proportion of overestimations of 50% or higher. The study of burn depth showed that 55% were equal to the estimates from the burn centre. Most studies had severe study limitations and the risk of imprecision was high. The overall certainty of evidence for accuracy of clinical estimations in referring centres is low (GRADE ⊕⊕ОО) for %TBSA and very low (GRADE ⊕ООО) for burn depth and resuscitation. CONCLUSION: Overestimation of %TBSA at referring hospitals occurs very frequently. The overall certainty of evidence for accuracy of clinical estimations in referring centres is low for burn size and very low for burn depth. The findings suggest that the burn community has a significant challenge in educating and communicating better with our colleagues at referring institutions and that high-quality studies are needed.
引用
- Brekke RL, Almeland SK, Hufthammer KO, et al. Agreement of clinical assessment of burn size and burn depth between referring hospitals and burn centres: A systematic review. Burns. 2022. PMID: 35843804. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2022.05.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。