在烧伤研究中使用小型与大型动物的优缺点:2021年研究特别兴趣小组会议纪要
2021年4月15日,美国烧伤协会研究特别兴趣小组在年会期间举办虚拟会议,以正反辩论形式讨论小型与大型动物模型在烧伤愈合/转化、瘢痕、吸入性损伤和脓毒症四个方面的优缺点。猪因皮肤解剖与人类相似而常被用作大型动物模型,但成本高且对劳力和资源要求高;仅吸入性损伤例外,有明确建立的羊模型。与会者一致认为小型与大型动物模型对回答烧伤反应的基础问题各有价值。
要点
- 猪因皮肤解剖与人类相似而常被用作大型动物模型。
- 羊模型用于吸入性损伤,大型气道便于使用支气管镜等临床工具。
- 大型动物模型昂贵且对劳力和资源要求高;大型动物烧伤脓毒症建模困难。
核心结论
- 与会者一致认为小型与大型动物模型对回答烧伤损伤反应的基础问题各有价值。
- 本文总结了专家意见及随后的讨论,希望有助于未来研究的实验设计。
研究设计与样本
- 2021年4月15日,美国烧伤协会研究特别兴趣小组在年会期间举办虚拟会议。
- 会议以正反辩论形式讨论小型与大型动物模型在烧伤愈合/转化、瘢痕、吸入性损伤和脓毒症四个方面的优缺点。
- 每个主题由两名有经验的研究者(小型和大型动物模型各一名)描述这些临床前模型的优缺点。
主要发现
- 猪因皮肤解剖与人类相似而常被用作大型动物模型。
- 吸入性损伤例外,有明确建立的羊模型;这两种物种气道较大,便于使用支气管镜等临床工具。
- 这些模型昂贵且对劳力和资源要求高。
- 已实施多种策略使更廉价的啮齿类动物模型适合回答烧伤中特定的关注问题。
- 在大型动物中建立烧伤脓毒症模型已被证明困难。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Multiple animal species and approaches have been used for modeling different aspects of burn care, with some strategies considered more appropriate or translatable than others. On April 15, 2021, the Research Special Interest Group of the American Burn Association held a virtual session as part of the agenda for the annual meeting. The session was set up as a pro/con debate on the use of small versus large animals for application to four important aspects of burn pathophysiology: burn healing/conversion, scarring, inhalation injury, and sepsis. For each of these topics, two experienced investigators (one each for small and large animal models) described the advantages and disadvantages of using these preclinical models. The use of swine as a large animal model was a common theme due to anatomic similarities with human skin. The exception to this was a well-defined ovine model of inhalation injury; both of these species have larger airways which allow for incorporation of clinical tools such as bronchoscopes. However, these models are expensive and demanding from labor and resource standpoints. Various strategies have been implemented to make the more inexpensive rodent models appropriate for answering specific questions of interest in burns. Moreover, modeling burn-sepsis in large animals has proven difficult. It was agreed that the use of both small and large animal models has merit for answering basic questions about the responses to burn injury. Expert opinion and the ensuing lively conversations are summarized herein, which we hope will help inform experimental design of future research.
引用
- Burmeister DM, Supp DM, Clark RA, et al. Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Small and Large Animals in Burn Research: Proceedings of the 2021 Research Special Interest Group. J Burn Care Res. 2022. PMID: 35778269. doi:10.1093/jbcr/irac091
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。