美容外科委员会认证:在线广告行为考察
本研究考察美国美容外科委员会(ABCS)认证医师在在线广告中使用「整形外科」和「整形外科医生」称谓的情况。共纳入298名非美国整形外科委员会认证的ABCS认证医师,结果显示189名(69.5%)将Facebook商业页面归类为「整形外科医生」,123名(57.2%)在Instagram使用#plasticsurgeon标签,172名(80.0%)使用#plasticsurgery标签。作者结论认为ABCS认证医师频繁使用这些称谓,尽管缺乏认证的整形外科培训或委员会认证,可能违反部分州的真实广告法并增加公众对不同委员会认证的困惑。
要点
- 298名ABCS认证医师中189名(69.5%)将Facebook商业页面归类为「整形外科医生」。
- Instagram帖子中123名(57.2%)使用#plasticsurgeon标签,172名(80.0%)使用#plasticsurgery标签。
- 专业网站上90名(30.4%)自称「整形外科医生」,123名(41.6%)将执业描述为「整形外科」,196名(68.5%)使用ABCS证书标明为「委员会认证」的美容外科医生。
核心结论
- ABCS认证医师在在线广告中频繁使用「整形外科医生」和「整形外科」称谓,尽管缺乏认证的整形外科培训或委员会认证。
- 大多数ABCS认证医师使用ABCS证书将自己营销为「委员会认证」的美容外科医生,可能违反部分州由美国医学会支持的真实广告法,并增加公众对不同委员会认证的困惑。
研究设计与样本
- 从ABCS网站识别ABCS认证医师,通过在线搜索定位其专业网站、Facebook商业页面和Instagram个人资料,记录「plastic」描述词和ABCS委员会认证的使用情况、Facebook商业页面分类以及Instagram上整形外科相关标签的使用。
- 共纳入298名非美国整形外科委员会认证的ABCS认证医师。
主要发现
- 189名(69.5%)将Facebook商业页面归类为「整形外科医生」。
- Instagram帖子中,123名(57.2%)使用#plasticsurgeon,172名(80.0%)使用#plasticsurgery。
- 专业网站上,90名(30.4%)自称「整形外科医生」,123名(41.6%)将执业描述为「整形外科」,196名(68.5%)使用ABCS证书标明为「委员会认证」的美容外科医生。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Aesthetic surgery patients commonly use online resources to select a surgeon. The American Board of Plastic Surgery is the American Board of Medical Specialties member board that certifies plastic surgeons. The American Board of Cosmetic Surgery (ABCS) provides aesthetic surgery credentials through a non-American Board of Medical Specialties-recognized process. This study examines use of the phrases "plastic surgery" and "plastic surgeon" by ABCS-certified surgeons when advertising online. METHODS: Diplomates of the ABCS were identified from the ABCS Web site. Professional Web sites, Facebook business pages, and Instagram profiles were located by online search. Use of the descriptor "plastic" and ABCS board certification on practice Web sites, Facebook business page categorization, and plastic surgery-related hashtag use on Instagram were recorded. RESULTS: A total of 298 non-American Board of Plastic Surgery-certified ABCS diplomates were included. One hundred eighty-nine (69.5%) categorized their Facebook business page as "plastic surgeon." Within Instagram posts, 123 (57.2%) used #plasticsurgeon, and 172 (80.0%) used #plasticsurgery. On professional Web sites, 90 (30.4%) identified themselves as a "plastic surgeon," 123 (41.6%) characterized their practice as "plastic surgery," and 196 (68.5%) used their ABCS credential to identify as a "board-certified" cosmetic surgeon. CONCLUSIONS: Diplomates of the ABCS frequently use "plastic surgeon" and "plastic surgery" in online advertisements despite a lack of accredited plastic surgery training or board certification. Furthermore, most ABCS diplomates use their ABCS credentials to market themselves as "board-certified" cosmetic surgeons, potentially violating American Medical Association-supported truth in advertising laws in some states and increasing public confusion regarding different board certifications.
引用
- Chen S, Makhoul AT, Janis JE, et al. Board Certification in Cosmetic Surgery: An Examination of Online Advertising Practices. Ann Plast Surg. 2022. PMID: 35690940. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000003120
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。