美容与整形外科中认知能力的教学与评估
该研究基于乳房隆术与屈肌腱修复术的先验认知任务分析、文献及现场观察,构建模糊逻辑认知地图比较两种手术的心理模型,识别出适用于整形外科的五个认知能力域,并提出教学与评估框架。
要点
- 识别出情境意识、决策、任务管理、领导力、沟通与团队合作五个认知能力域。
- 比较两种手术心理模型可揭示择期与创伤情境下决策过程的差异。
- 提出将认知能力映射至通用心理模型的框架及相应培训方法。
核心结论
- 通过比较两种不同手术的心理模型,引入整形外科不同情境下的认知能力,以指导此类能力的教学与评估。
研究设计与样本
- 基于先验认知任务分析、文献来源及乳房隆术与屈肌腱修复术的现场观察,为每种手术生成任务清单。
- 使用模糊逻辑认知地图开发两种心理模型,以可视化并分析两种手术中使用的认知过程。
- 借助文献辅助模型比较,定义所运用的认知能力、识别决策过程差异,并提供理解认知能力的指导框架。
主要发现
- 从文献中识别出适用于整形外科的五个不同认知能力域:情境意识、决策、任务管理、领导力、沟通与团队合作。
- 识别出择期与创伤情境下所采用决策过程的差异。
- 综合出一个将认知能力映射至手术护理通用心理模型内的框架,并建议了此类能力的培训方法。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cognition, part of surgical competence, employs forward planning, error prevention, and orchestration of technical skills. Thus, an understanding of mental processes used by experts throughout patient care is essential to teaching such competencies. The authors' study aimed to analyze and compare mental models of two distinct procedures in plastic surgery-breast augmentation and flexor tendon repair-to develop a framework to define cognitive competencies in plastic surgery aided by a review of the literature. METHODS: Based on data from a priori cognitive task analyses, literary sources, and field observations of breast augmentation surgery and flexor tendon repair, task lists were produced for each procedure. Two mental models were developed using fuzzy logic cognitive maps to visually illustrate and analyze cognitive processes used in either procedure. A comparison of the models aided by literature was used to define the cognitive competencies employed, identify differences in the decision-making process, and provide a guiding framework for understanding cognitive competencies. RESULTS: Five distinct cognitive competency domains were identified from the literature applicable to plastic surgery: situation awareness, decision-making, task management, leadership, and communication and teamwork. Differences in processes of decision-making utilized between an elective and a trauma setting were identified. A framework to map cognitive competencies within a generic mental model in surgical care was synthesized, and methods were suggested for training on such competencies. CONCLUSION: Cognitive competencies in different settings in plastic surgery are introduced using a comparative study of two mental models of distinct procedures to guide the teaching and assessment of such competencies.
引用
- Al-Halabi B, Vassiliou M, Gilardino M, et al. Teaching and Assessing Cognitive Competencies in Aesthetic and Plastic Surgery. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2022. PMID: 35687398. doi:10.1097/PRS.0000000000009295
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。