文献速递烧伤

加纳健康个体对口服补液饮料的偏好:一项单盲横断面调查,为烧伤肠内复苏方案的实施提供依据

Preferences for oral rehydration drinks among healthy individuals in Ghana: A single-blind, cross-sectional survey to inform implementation of an enterally based resuscitation protocol for burn injury.
PubMed 文献 · Burns · 2022-05-20

该研究在加纳对60名健康儿童、成人和老年人进行单盲横断面调查,评估五种口服补液盐和一种阳性对照饮料的适口性与总体可接受性;多数参与者认为阳性对照和柠檬味、橙味口服补液盐味道好或很好,而自制和低渗口服补液盐评价较低;作者认为肠内复苏方案可优先纳入柑橘味口服补液盐。

要点

  • 阳性对照饮料、柠檬味口服补液盐和橙味口服补液盐被评为「好」或「很好」的比例分别为89%、78%和78%。
  • 自制口服补液盐和低渗口服补液盐被评为「好」或「很好」的比例仅为20%和15%。
  • 各年龄组间味道差异不大,但儿童比成人和老年人更常对调味和甜味饮料给出积极评价。

核心结论

  • 这些发现可用于支持制定在肠内复苏患者中可能更易接受的治疗方案,从而提高治疗效果;作者认为肠内复苏在有条件时应纳入柑橘味口服补液盐,因为其适口性更优,且似乎没有必要为不同年龄患者使用不同的调味添加剂。

研究设计与样本

  • 在加纳开展的单盲横断面调查,纳入60名健康儿童(5-14岁)、成人(15-54岁)和老年人(≥55岁),每个年龄组20人,评估五种口服补液盐和一种阳性对照饮料(Sprite Zero®)的适口性与总体可接受性。

主要发现

  • 阳性对照饮料被多数参与者(89%)评价为味道「好」或「很好」,其次为柠檬味口服补液盐(78%)和橙味口服补液盐(78%)。
  • 自制口服补液盐和低渗口服补液盐被评价为味道「好」或「很好」的参与者分别仅占20%和15%。
  • 各年龄组间无主要味道差异,但儿童比成人和老年人更常对调味和甜味饮料给出积极评价(即味道「好」或「很好」)。
  • 在假设严重受伤需要复苏的情况下,参与者倾向于更愿意饮用所有饮料,包括低渗和自制口服补液盐。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,肠内复苏在有条件时应纳入柑橘味口服补液盐,因为其适口性更优,且似乎没有必要为不同年龄患者使用不同的调味添加剂。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Enterally based resuscitation for major burn injuries has been suggested as a simple, operationally superior, and effective resuscitation strategy for use in austere contexts. However, key information to support its implementation is lacking, including palatability and acceptability of widely available rehydration drinks. METHODS: We performed a single-blinded, cross-sectional survey of 60 healthy children (5-14 years), adults (15-54 years) and older adults (≥55 years) to determine palatability and overall acceptability of five oral rehydration solutions (ORS) and a positive control drink (Sprite Zero®) in Ghana. Quantitative data were described and differences between our control drink and the others across age groups were visually examined with Likert plots. Qualitative responses were analyzed using a content analysis framework. RESULTS: Twenty participants in each age group completed the study. Participants were as young as 5 years and as old as 84 years. Nearly two thirds of the sample identified as male (n = 38, 63% of all participants). The positive control was reported to taste 'good or 'very good' by the majority of participants (89%) followed by lemon-flavored ORS (78%) and orange-flavored ORS (78%). Conversely, homemade and low-osmolarity ORS were reported to taste 'good' or 'very good' by only 20% and 15% of participants, respectively. There were no major taste differences across the age groups. However, children more frequently reported positively (i.e., tastes 'good' or 'very good') about flavored and sweet drinks than did adults and older adults. When faced with the hypothetical situation of being critically injured and needing resuscitation, participants tended to be more agreeable to consuming all the drinks, even low-osmolarity and homemade ORS. CONCLUSIONS: These findings can be used to support the development of protocols that may be more acceptable among patients undergoing enterally based resuscitation, thus improving the effectiveness of the treatment. Specifically, enterally based resuscitation should likely include citrus-flavored ORS when available, given superior palatability and the fact that different flavor additives for patients of different ages do not seem necessary.

来源:Burns,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gyedu A, Mehta K, Baidoo H, et al. Preferences for oral rehydration drinks among healthy individuals in Ghana: A single-blind, cross-sectional survey to inform implementation of an enterally based resuscitation protocol for burn injury. Burns. 2022. PMID: 35715342. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2022.05.016

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。