文献速递美容整形

评估YouTube上关于美容性脂肪移植患者信息的质量与可靠性

Assessing the quality and reliability of patient information regarding aesthetic fat grafting on YouTube.
PubMed 文献 · J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg · 2022-01-31

本研究评估YouTube上关于美容性脂肪移植的患者信息质量与可靠性。检索「脂肪移植」和「脂肪转移」结合「面部」「乳房」「臀部」「巴西提臀术」的组合,按观看次数筛选每种组合前20个独特英语美容手术相关视频,由三名独立评审者评分。结果显示76%视频由医生制作,24%由非专业人士制作,总体平均MD评分1.5、GQS评分2.6,医生制作视频评分高于非医学作者,但非专业人士和非整形外科医生视频观看量更高。结论认为YouTube上美容性脂肪移植视频信息质量低且来源不可靠,建议外科医生教育患者并呼吁专业学会传播高质量媒体。

要点

  • YouTube美容性脂肪移植视频总体信息质量低,平均MD评分1.5、GQS评分2.6。
  • 医生制作视频评分高于非医学作者(MD 1.6 vs 1.3;GQS 2.7 vs 2.2)。
  • 非专业人士和非整形外科医生视频观看量比医生视频高40%,点赞数多一倍,订阅数近两倍。

核心结论

  • YouTube上美容性脂肪移植手术视频呈现的信息总体质量低且来源不可靠。
  • 外科医生应教育患者关于潜在不准确信息,专业学会应传播高质量媒体。

研究设计与样本

  • 在YouTube检索「脂肪移植」和「脂肪转移」分别结合「面部」「乳房」「臀部」「巴西提臀术」,按观看次数筛选每种组合前20个独特、英语、美容手术相关视频,共80个视频,由三名独立评审者评审人口学和描述性特征。
  • 使用改良DISCERN(MD)工具(1=低,5=高)和全球质量量表(GQS)(1=差,5=优)对视频信息可靠性和质量进行评分。

主要发现

  • 80个视频中76%由医生制作,24%由非专业人士制作。
  • 总体平均MD评分为1.5,平均GQS为2.6。
  • 医生制作视频评分高于非医学作者(MD:1.6 vs 1.3;GQS:2.7 vs 2.2)。
  • 委员会认证整形外科医生视频(N=30)在MD(1.7 vs 1.3)和GQS(3.1 vs 2.2)上均高于非医学作者视频。
  • 非专业人士和非整形外科医生视频观看量多40%,点赞数多一倍,订阅数近两倍。

关键数值与推荐

  • MD评分标准:1=低,5=高。
  • GQS评分标准:1=差,5=优。
  • 总体平均MD评分1.5,平均GQS评分2.6。
  • 医生视频MD评分1.6 vs 非医学作者1.3;GQS评分2.7 vs 2.2。
  • 委员会认证整形外科医生视频(N=30)MD评分1.7 vs 非医学作者1.3;GQS评分3.1 vs 2.2。

临床怎么用

  • 外科医生应教育患者关于YouTube上美容性脂肪移植视频中潜在不准确的信息。
  • 专业学会应传播高质量媒体。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

PURPOSE: Patients increasingly consult social media regarding aesthetic surgery. Given the popularity of fat transfer operations, this study assesses the quality and reliability of patient information available on YouTube regarding aesthetic fat grafting. METHODS: The terms "fat grafting" and "fat transfer" were searched on YouTube with respect to the terms "face", "breast", "buttock", and "Brazilian butt lift". Filtered by view count, the top 20 unique, English language, aesthetic surgery-related videos for each search combination were reviewed by three independent reviewers for demographic and descriptive characteristics. Videos were rated for information reliability and quality using the modified DISCERN (MD) tool (1 = low, 5 = high) and global quality scale (GQS) (1 = poor, 5 = excellent). RESULTS: Out of 80 total videos, 76% were authored by physicians and 24% by laypersons. The overall mean MD score was 1.5 and the mean GQS was 2.6. Videos authored by physicians outscored those by non-medical authors (MD: 1.6 vs. 1.3; GQS 2.7 vs. 2.2). Board-certified plastic surgeon videos (N = 30) scored higher on both the MD (1.7 vs 1.3) and GQS (3.1 vs 2.2) than those of non-medical authors. On the contrary, videos by laypersons and non-plastic surgeons had 40% more views, twice as many "likes" and nearly double as many subscribers. CONCLUSION: The overall quality of information presented in aesthetic fat grafting procedures videos on YouTube is low and from unreliable sources. Surgeons should educate patients regarding potentially inaccurate information, and professional societies should disseminate high-quality media.

来源:J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Dembinski D, Moore MG, Effendi M, et al. Assessing the quality and reliability of patient information regarding aesthetic fat grafting on YouTube. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg. 2022. PMID: 35272959. doi:10.1016/j.bjps.2022.01.053

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。