交互式沉浸虚拟现实与静态自然图片在烧伤创面护理中作为分散注意力镇痛方法的比较
研究比较交互式沉浸虚拟现实(VR)与同款VR眼镜观看自然图片在烧伤清创中的镇痛效果,48例严重烧伤患者(44例成人、4例儿童)参与,第1天44例比较两种VR条件,第2天13例比较VR与无分散注意力。第1天两种VR条件最痛评分无显著差异;第2天VR条件较无分散注意力最痛评分显著降低。
要点
- 第1天交互式VR与自然图片条件最痛评分无显著差异(71.06 vs 68.19)。
- 第2天VR条件最痛评分显著低于无分散注意力(54.23 vs 63.85,p<.05)。
- 研究首次显示便携防水沉浸VR在成人烧伤清创中的可行性,但交互式VR未比自然图片更有效镇痛。
核心结论
- 研究首次显示在成人烧伤清创中使用定制便携防水沉浸式VR硬件的可行性。
- 与预测相反,交互式VR并未比同款VR眼镜观看自然刺激更有效地减轻疼痛。
研究设计与样本
- 采用受试者内设计,条件顺序随机化,共48例严重烧伤患者(44例成人、4例儿童)。
- 第1天44例参与,每人分别在交互式沉浸VR环境和同款VR眼镜观看静态自然照片与自然声音下各进行5分钟创面护理。
- 第2天13例参与(12例成人和1例青少年),每人分别在不分散注意力和使用新型防水VR系统下各进行5分钟烧伤创面护理。
主要发现
- 第1天,计算机生成世界条件最痛评分均值71.06(SD=26.86),自然图片条件均值68.19(SD=29.26),两者无显著差异(t<1,NS)。
- 第1天,计算机生成VR条件积极情感(趣味性)更高、真实感更低,疼痛不愉快感和VR临场感无显著差异。
- 第2天,VR条件最痛评分均值54.23(SD=26.13),无分散注意力条件均值63.85(SD=31.50),VR条件显著更低(t(11)=1.91,p<.05,SD=17.38)。
- 第2天,VR条件下思考疼痛的时间显著更少,积极情感显著更高。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: Non-pharmacologic adjuncts to opioid analgesics for burn wound debridement enhance safety and cost effectiveness in care. The current study explored the feasibility of using a custom portable water-friendly immersive VR hardware during burn debridement in adults, and tested whether interactive VR would reduce pain more effectively than nature stimuli viewed in the same VR goggles. METHODS: Forty-eight patients with severe burn injuries (44 adults and 4 children) had their burn injuries debrided and dressed in a wet wound care environment on Study Day 1, and 13 also participated in Study Day 2. INTERVENTION: The study used a within-subject design to test two hypotheses (one hypothesis per study day) with the condition order randomized. On Study Day 1, each individual (n = 44 participants) spent 5 min of wound care in an interactive immersive VR environment designed for burn care, and 5 min looking at still nature photos and sounds of nature in the same VR goggles. On Study Day 2 (n = 12 adult participants and one adolescent from Day 1), each participant spent 5 min of burn wound care with no distraction and 5 min of wound care in VR, using a new water-friendly VR system. On both days, during a post-wound care assessment, participants rated and compared the pain they had experienced in each condition. OUTCOME MEASURES ON STUDY DAYS 1 AND 2: Worst pain during burn wound care was the primary dependent variable. Secondary measures were ratings of time spent thinking about pain during wound care, pain unpleasantness, and positive affect during wound care. RESULTS: On Study Day 1, no significant differences in worst pain ratings during wound care were found between the computer-generated world (Mean = 71.06, SD = 26.86) vs. Nature pictures conditions (Mean = 68.19, SD = 29.26; t < 1, NS). On secondary measures, positive affect (fun) was higher, and realism was lower during computer-generated VR. No significant differences in pain unpleasantness or "presence in VR" between the two conditions were found, however. VR VS. NO VR. (STUDY DAY 2): Participants reported significantly less worst pain when distracted with adjunctive computer generated VR than during standard wound care without distraction (Mean = 54.23, SD = 26.13 vs 63.85, SD = 31.50, t(11) = 1.91, p < .05, SD = 17.38). In addition, on Study Day 2, "time spent thinking about pain during wound care" was significantly less during the VR condition, and positive affect was significantly greater during VR, compared to the No VR condition. CONCLUSION: The current study is innovative in that it is the first to show the feasibility of using a custom portable water-friendly immersive VR hardware during burn debridement in adults. However, contrary to predictions, interactive VR did not reduce pain more effectively than nature stimuli viewed in the same VR goggles.
引用
- Patterson DR, Drever S, Soltani M, et al. A comparison of interactive immersive virtual reality and still nature pictures as distraction-based analgesia in burn wound care. Burns. 2022. PMID: 35305845. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2022.02.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。