「铁窗后的烧伤」:监狱囚犯烧伤的10年回顾与费用分析及烧伤外展服务的作用
该研究回顾性分析2007至2017年三家地区监狱转诊至烧伤中心的18例囚犯烧伤病例,94%为烫伤,56%继发于袭击,主要使用水壶且多累及面部和躯干,平均烧伤面积2.89%,72.2%住院平均4天,全部非手术治疗。作者建议开展针对性教育并由烧伤外展团队为监狱医务人员提供培训。
要点
- 18例监狱烧伤中94%为烫伤,56%继发于袭击,主要工具为水壶,多累及面部和躯干。
- 平均烧伤面积2.89%(<1-8%),72.2%住院平均4天,全部经敷料非手术治疗。
- 转诊量随时间指数增长,44%发生在2017年,67%来自单一监狱。
核心结论
- 作者建议开展针对性教育以减少监狱烧伤发生率并确保充分处理,因转诊量明显上升。
- 烧伤外展团队可为监狱内部医务人员提供培训并审核转诊至专科烧伤服务的病例,旨在确保公平照护的同时降低转运和住院管理费用。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性病例系列,纳入2007至2017年从地区监狱转诊至本中心的全部烧伤病例。
- 共记录来自三家地区监狱的18例病例,其中67%来自单一监狱。
- 使用既往发表的框架进行照护费用分析。
主要发现
- 转诊量随时间指数增长,44%发生在2017年。
- 94%为烫伤,56%继发于袭击,主要使用水壶,多累及面部和躯干。
- 平均烧伤面积为2.89%(<1-8%),80%接受了急救处理。
- 72.2%住院,平均住院4天;全部烧伤经敷料非手术治疗,平均接受2次门诊复查(1-8次)。
- 近半数病例合并物理创伤,给管理带来挑战。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议开展针对性教育以减少监狱烧伤发生率并确保充分处理。
- 作者提出烧伤外展团队可为监狱内部医务人员提供培训并审核转诊至专科烧伤服务的病例。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: From 85348 inmates in England and Wales, over 26,000 incidents of assault and 40,000 of self-harm were reported from within prisons in 2016. This study focuses primarily on burn injuries in prison, determining the predominant aetiology as well as clinical outcomes of these injuries. METHODS: Data was retrieved retrospectively and a case series performed, including all burns referred from regional prisons to our centre from 2007 to 2017 and comprising patient demographics, mechanism of injury, total body surface area affected, management, and outcome. Cost analysis of care was conducted using a previously published framework. RESULTS: 18 cases from three regional prisons were recorded, with 67% from a single prison. Referrals rose exponentially over time, with 44% occurring in 2017. 94% were scald burns, and 56% secondary to assault, primarily through the use of kettles and mostly targeting the face and trunk. The mean TBSA of burn was 2.89% (<1-8%), and 80% received first aid. 72.2% were admitted to hospital for an average of 4 days. All burns were managed nonoperatively with dressings and underwent on average 2 outpatient reviews (1-8). DISCUSSION: The disproportionate spread of referrals across the prisons correlates partly with the respective populations, but may also represent contrasting medical provisions. The recurring method of assault reflects the relative ease of access to hot water as a harmful agent, predominantly presenting with scalds affecting more critical areas, and with concurrent physical trauma in nearly half of cases which presents management challenges. CONCLUSION: Targeted education is recommended to reduce the incidence and ensure adequate management of burns in prison, referrals for which are demonstrably rising. Accordingly, the Burns Outreach team can provide training to in-house prison health staff and review referrals to specialist Burns services, aiming to ensure equitable care while alleviating costs associated with transfer to and management in hospital.
引用
- Jawad AM, Nyeko-Lacek M, Brown L, et al. "Burns Behind Bars": A 10-year review and cost analysis of burn injuries in prison inmates presenting to a regional burns centre, and the role of the burns outreach service. Burns. 2021. PMID: 34974930. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2021.12.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。