烧伤治疗证据基础的趋势分析及11年间随机对照试验的质量评估
该研究通过人工筛查2009年1月1日至2020年6月1日《Burns》和《Journal of Burn Care and Research》的全部文章,并检索PubMed获取其他期刊的烧伤随机对照试验和Meta分析,评估高证据 publications 的数量趋势,并用改良CONSORT清单对随机对照试验进行质量评估。共评估5145篇文章,其中高证据出版物占2.83%(n=237),最终128项随机对照试验纳入质量评估,报告最充分的条目是纳入和排除标准(n=111;86.72%),最不充分的是分配隐藏(n=22;13.92%)。结论认为高证据出版物呈积极趋势,但随机对照试验对多个CONSORT条目的报告仍较差,提倡遵循标准报告指南以提高报告质量。
要点
- 2009年至2020年6月,《Burns》和《Journal of Burn Care and Research》共发表5145篇文章,其中高证据出版物占2.83%(n=237)。
- 最终128项随机对照试验纳入质量评估,最常见的主题是创面愈合(n=28;21.88%)。
- 报告最充分的CONSORT条目是纳入和排除标准(n=111;86.72%),最不充分的是分配隐藏(n=22;13.92%)。
核心结论
- 研究观察到高证据出版物呈积极趋势,但随机对照试验对多个CONSORT条目的报告仍较差,提倡遵循标准报告指南以提高报告质量。
研究设计与样本
- 通过PubMed检索工具和Single Citation Matcher功能识别《Burns》和《Journal of Burn Care and Research》的全部文章,并人工筛查2009年1月1日至2020年6月1日(含)的文章。
- 另在PubMed检索英语烧伤随机对照试验和Meta分析(MESH词为burns),以识别其他期刊中的随机对照试验和Meta分析。
- 使用改良CONSORT清单评估随机对照试验的报告质量。
主要发现
- 共评估5145篇文章,其中《Burns》3230篇(62.78%),《Journal of Burn Care and Research》1915篇(37.22%)。
- 0.012%为随机对照试验的Meta分析,0.30%为其他Meta分析,2.52%最初被识别为随机对照试验。
- 高证据出版物数量显著增加,但仅占总量的2.83%(n=237)。
- 在其他期刊中另识别出95项随机对照试验,其中58项纳入质量分析。
- 最终128项随机对照试验符合质量评估条件,最常见的单个主题为创面愈合(n=28;21.88%)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Previous articles assessed the evidence-base for the treatment of burns, but the latest was published in 2010, examining data up to and inclusive of 2008. The aim of this article is to examine the trend in the number of high-evidence publications over the subsequent 11-year period and quality-assess RCTs within this timeframe. MATERIALS AND METHODS: All articles published in Burns and Journal of Burn Care and Research (JBCR) were identified using PubMed Search Tools and its Single Citation Matcher function. These journals were manually screened from 01/01/2009-01/06/2020 inclusive. Additionally, a PubMed search was conducted searching for RCTs and meta-analyses in English with the MESH term burns to identify meta-analyses and RCTs in all other journals. The reporting of RCTs was assessed using a modified CONsolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) checklist. RESULTS: A total of 5145 articles were evaluated from Burns and JBCR, with 3230 (62.78%) from Burns and 1915 (37.22%) from JBCR. 0.012% were meta-analyses of RCTs, 0.30% were other meta-analyses, and 2.52% were initially identified as RCTs. Whilst a significant increase in the number of high-evidence publications is observed, these represent 2.83% (n = 237) of the total. An additional 95 RCTs were identified in other journals, 58 being included in quality-analysis. A total 128 RCTs were thus eligible for quality-assessment, the most popular individual topic being wound healing (n = 28; 21.88%). The most highly reported criterion was listed inclusion and exclusion criteria (n = 111; 86.72%) and the least reported criterion was allocation concealment (n = 22; 13.92%). CONCLUSIONS: This study observes a positive trend in high-evidence publications. The reporting of several CONSORT criteria in RCTs remains poor. Observation to standard reporting guidelines is advocated to improve the quality of reporting.
引用
- Mihailidis TH, Al-Benna S. Examining trends in the evidence base for the treatment of burns and a quality assessment of randomised controlled trials over an 11-year period. Burns. 2021. PMID: 34998668. doi:10.1016/j.burns.2021.11.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。