学术出版的灰色地带导航:避免掠夺性出版商并建立你的「白名单」
本文回顾学术出版从订阅制向开放获取(OA)的转变,分析掠夺性期刊利用作者付费模式带来的风险,并讨论内容获取、许可、索引和期刊计量等议题,进而评估整形与重建外科领域高可见度OA期刊,为作者提供评估期刊合法性与可见度的基本框架。
要点
- 掠夺性期刊利用作者付费模式,以可信出版平台的虚假承诺牟利。
- 掠夺性期刊与合法但不够成熟的新期刊难以区分,损害外科医生和科学家的信誉。
- 本文评估整形与重建外科高可见度OA期刊,并建立评估期刊合法性与可见度的基本框架。
核心结论
- 本文旨在为作者提供评估期刊合法性与可见度的基本框架,以应对合法与非法之间的灰色地带。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为叙述性综述,回顾学术出版历史及内容获取、许可、索引和期刊计量等选定议题,并评估整形与重建外科领域高可见度OA期刊。
主要发现
- OA模式在扩张受众、改善公共获取、减少内容重用限制和加快出版速度的同时,也带来了掠夺性期刊等意外弊端。
- 掠夺性期刊利用作者付费出版模式,以可信出版平台的虚假承诺进行欺骗。
- 掠夺性期刊难以与合法但不够成熟的新期刊区分,对许多专业领域外科医生和科学家的信誉造成破坏性影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Academic publishing has undergone a transition from print-based, subscription access journals targeted toward physicians and scientists to the widely accessible, open access (OA) format made possible by the Internet. The objectives of OA broadly include audience expansion and improved public access to publicly funded research, reduction of limitations on content reuse and alteration, and prompt turnaround from submission to publication. Despite well-intended founding principles, unexpected disadvantages of the OA model have arisen including the emergence of predatory journals, which exploit the author-pays publishing model with the deceptive promise of reputable publishing platforms. Predatory journals can be difficult to discern from the legitimate yet unsophisticated novice journal, which represents a destructive influence on the credibility of surgeons and scientists within many specialties. As an author, when the highly reputable, "whitelisted" journals in our field are not available or interested in the scope of our work, how can we ensure authenticity of those journals that exist in the gray area between legitimate and illegitimate? Given these questions, the goal of this article is to demystify the history and selected issues that surround academic publication including content access, licensing, indexing, and journal metrics. With this background, we then evaluate highly visible OA journals in plastic and reconstructive surgery and build a basic framework, which authors can use to evaluate a journal for legitimacy and visibility.
引用
- Soteropulos CE, Poore SO. Navigating the Gray of Academic Publication: Avoiding Predatory Publishers and Creating Your "Whitelist". Ann Plast Surg. 2021. PMID: 34818289. doi:10.1097/SAP.0000000000002902
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。