抗菌药物轮换对医院内细菌耐药率影响的系统综述
9项研究比较轮换与对照组结果矛盾,3项比较轮换与混合策略未显示优劣,其余研究结果亦不一致。综述认为缺乏稳健设计和标准化方案,现有数据不支持轮换能改善医院内耐药率。
要点
- 抗菌药物轮换对医院内细菌耐药率的影响证据不足且结果矛盾。
- 轮换与抗菌药物混合策略相比未显示任一策略更优。
- 研究方案在周期长度、药物选择、降阶梯机会等参数上差异大,限制可重复性。
核心结论
- 缺乏稳健设计和标准化方案限制得出安全结论,但现有数据不支持轮换能改善医院内耐药率。
研究设计与样本
- 系统文献综述检索PubMed/MedLine、Embase、CINAHL Plus和Global Health数据库。
主要发现
- 9项研究评估轮换与对照组,结果矛盾。
- 3项研究比较轮换与抗菌药物混合策略,未显示任一策略更优。
- 其余研究评估各轮换药物的耐药动态,结果亦不一致。
局限性
- 研究方案在周期长度、抗菌药物选择、降阶梯至窄谱药物的机会及附带损害指标测量等方面存在差异,限制了对结果可重复性和整体政策效果的评估。
- 仅一项随机研究,多数为准实验设计,证据等级有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
AIMS: Antimicrobial resistance is an evolving phenomenon with alarming public health consequences. Antibiotic cycling is a widely known antimicrobial stewardship initiative that encompasses periodical shifts in empirical treatment protocols with the aim of limiting selective pressures on bacterial populations. We present a review of the evidence regarding the actual impact of antimicrobial cycling on bacterial resistance control within hospitals. METHODS: A systematic literature review was conducted using the PubMed/MedLine, Embase, CINAHL Plus and Global Health databases. RESULTS: A systematic search process retrieved a sole randomised study, and so we broadened inclusion criteria to encompass quasi-experimental designs. Fifteen studies formed our dataset including seven prospective trials and eight before-and-after studies. Nine studies evaluated cycling vs. a control group and produced conflicting results whilst three studies compared cycling with antibiotic mixing, with none of the strategies appearing superior. The rest evaluated resistance dynamics of each of the on-cycle antibiotics with contradictory findings. Research protocols differed in parameters such as the cycle length, the choice of antibiotics, the opportunity to de-escalate to narrow-spectrum agents and the measurement of indicators of collateral damage. This limited our ability to evaluate the replicability of findings and the overall policy effects. CONCLUSION: Dearth of robust designs and standardised protocols limits our ability to reach safe conclusions. Nonetheless, in view of the available data we find no reason to believe that cycling should be expected to improve antibiotic resistance rates within hospitals.
引用
- Chatzopoulou M, Reynolds L. Systematic review of the effects of antimicrobial cycling on bacterial resistance rates within hospital settings. Br J Clin Pharmacol. 2021. PMID: 34409640. doi:10.1111/bcp.15042
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。