评估COVID-19疫苗在两国药物警戒数据库中的遮蔽与去遮蔽方法
本研究回顾性分析荷兰Lareb和西班牙FEDRA药物警戒数据库中COVID-19疫苗对比例失衡分析的遮蔽效应,并比较两种去遮蔽干预:剔除所有涉及COVID-19疫苗的药物-事件组合(DEC)与仅剔除有影响的离群DEC。结果显示COVID-19疫苗在两国数据库均造成显著遮蔽,两种方法均可揭示新的比例报告信号(SDR),但影响程度不同,选择应基于数据库背景。
要点
- COVID-19疫苗在Lareb和FEDRA数据库中均造成显著遮蔽效应。
- 粗剔除(剔除所有涉及COVID-19疫苗的DEC)比离群剔除排除更多DEC(2.1% vs 0.1%),对SDR影响更大。
- 两种去遮蔽方法均能揭示新的SDR,但效果因数据库而异,应个体化选择。
核心结论
- COVID-19疫苗在荷兰Lareb和西班牙FEDRA数据库中均造成显著遮蔽效应。
- 两种去遮蔽策略均能有效揭示新的SDR,但影响程度不同,选择应基于数据库背景。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,基于荷兰Lareb和西班牙FEDRA两个国家药物警戒数据库。
- 比较两种去遮蔽干预:剔除所有涉及COVID-19疫苗的DEC(粗剔除)与仅剔除有影响的离群DEC(离群剔除)。
- 通过重新计算报告比值比(ROR)探索遮蔽效应,并分析重要医学事件(IME)子集。
主要发现
- 粗剔除和离群剔除均导致报告数、DEC数和SDR数减少。
- 在Lareb和FEDRA中,粗剔除排除2.1%的DEC,离群剔除排除0.1%。
- 粗剔除使SDR减少9.8%(Lareb)和3.9%(FEDRA),离群剔除使SDR减少5.7%和1.1%。
- Lareb中粗剔除揭示1301个SDR(20个IME相关),离群剔除揭示1942个SDR(95个IME相关)。
- FEDRA中粗剔除和离群剔除分别揭示1453和1226个SDR,其中IME相关分别为41和70个。
临床怎么用
- 在COVID-19疫苗大规模接种后,应评估药物警戒数据库中的遮蔽效应。
- 去遮蔽方法的选择应结合数据库特征,粗剔除和离群剔除各有优势。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The COVID-19 mass vaccination led to a substantial increase in spontaneous reports submitted to pharmacovigilance (PV) databases, potentially introducing masking effects that could conceal safety signals. OBJECTIVES: To examine the masking effect of COVID-19 vaccines on disproportionality analyses and to compare two unmasking interventions in the Dutch (Lareb database) and Spanish (Farmacovigilancia Española, Datos de Reacciones Adversas, FEDRA) national PV databases: removal of all drug-event combinations (DEC) involving a COVID-19 vaccine versus excluding influential outliers DECs only. METHODS: The masking effect was explored retrospectively on the basis of the number of signals of disproportionate reporting (SDR). DECs involving a COVID-19 vaccine were excluded using crude and outlier techniques, and reporting odds ratios were recalculated. Subsets of important medical events (IME) were analysed in both databases. RESULTS: Both crude and influential outlier removal methods led to reductions in the number of reports, DECs and SDRs. Both in the Lareb database and FEDRA, crude removal excluded 2.1% of DECs, while the outlier method excluded 0.1%. Crude removal had a greater impact on SDRs, reducing them by 9.8% in the Lareb database and 3.9% in FEDRA, compared with 5.7% and 1.1% with the outlier method. In the Lareb database, 1301 SDRs (20 IME-related) were unmasked using crude removal, and 1942 (95 IME-related) with the outlier method. FEDRA showed 1453 and 1226 SDRs unmasked, including 41 and 70 IME-related. CONCLUSIONS: COVID-19 vaccines caused substantial masking in both databases. Both strategies effectively revealed new SDRs, though their impact varied. The choice of approach should be tailored to the database context.
引用
- Rachwal O, Gutiérrez-Lobón M, Cueto NS, et al. Evaluating COVID-19 Vaccine Masking and Unmasking Methods in Two National Pharmacovigilance Databases. Drug Saf. 2026. PMID: 41501319. doi:10.1007/s40264-025-01644-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。